Akhlaq Bina Khuda Ke: Kya Naiki Apne Pairon Par Khari Ho Sakti Hai?
"Agar Khuda nahi to sab kuch jaiz hai" — Dostoevsky ka yeh jumla aksar aik tanbeeh ke taur par dohraya jata hai. Magar kya yeh tanbeeh hai ya sawal? Yeh mazmoon akhlaq ki chaar ghair-ilahiyati buniyadon ko, momin ke behtareen jawab ko, aur us sawal ko pesh karta hai jo dono ke liye khula hai: pabandi ka "chahiye" aata kahan se hai?
By· July 2, 2026· 9 min read
Aam guftagu mein Khuda ke haq mein jo dalil sab se zyada di jati hai, wo kainat ya tareekh ki nahi — akhlaq ki hai: Khuda ke baghair koi asli sahi aur ghalat nahi — sirf pasand, riwaj, aur taqat. Ivan Karamazov ka formula is ka parcham hai: agar Khuda nahi, to sab kuch jaiz hai.
Yeh dalil ghor se sunne ke laiq hai, kyunke is mein aik sacha mushahida aik mashkook nateeje mein lipta hua hai. Sacha mushahida yeh: akhlaq zauq se barh kar mehsoos hota hai — us ke taqaze khud ko lazim ke taur par pesh karte hain, chahe humein pasand hon ya na hon. Mashkook natija yeh: ke sirf aik ilahi qanoon-saaz hi unhein lazim bana sakta hai. Kya yeh natija sacha hai? Aaiye is sawal ke saath imandari se chalein.
Sab Se Purana Etiraz
Continue Reading
Continue reading this article
Sign in free to read in full. Become a member to join the discussion without limits.
Sign in free to read →- ✓Read every article
- ✓Comment and reply (up to 100 words, 10/month)
- ✓Browse the community
- ✓Reader badge