John Shaqi

Science Aur Takhleeq: Kya Yeh Jang Hai, Aur Kis Ki?

Big Bang ka nazariya aik padri ne diya, genetics aik monk ne, aur Darwin ka sab se bara hami aik pakka Isai tha. To "science banam mazhab" ki jang kis ne banai — aur kya wo asli hai? Yeh mazmoon Galileo se le kar evolution tak, aur God-of-the-gaps se le kar scientism tak, dono taraf ke dawon ki talashi leta hai.

ByJohn Shaqi· July 2, 2026· 10 min read

Hamare zamane ki sab se mash''hoor kahani yeh hai: aik taraf science hai — roshni, dalil, taraqqi; doosri taraf mazhab — andhera, aqeeda, muzahamat; aur dono mein sadiyon se jang hai. Yeh kahani itni bar sunai gayi hai ke sach lagne lagi hai. Is mazmoon ka pehla kaam is kahani ki talashi hai — aur talashi mein jo nikle ga, wo dono taraf ke liye takleef-deh hai.

Jang Ki Kahani Kahan Se Aayi?

"Conflict thesis" ka naam tareekh-daan jante hain: yeh do kitabon se phaili — Draper (1874) aur White (1896). Aaj science ki tareekh ke scholars is thesis ko taqreeban ittefaq se radd karte hain — Ronald Numbers ki Galileo Goes to Jail is par poori kitab hai. Haqeeqat zyada dilchasp hai: Big Bang ka nazariya Georges Lemaître ne diya — Catholic padri. Genetics Gregor Mendel ne banai — monk, apne khanqah ke bagh mein. Newton apni physics se zyada waqt theology par likhta tha. Aur jis "Islamic golden age" ka zikr hum Islam ke mazmoon mein kar chuke hain — algebra, optics, tibb — wo masjid ke saye mein hua. Science ka jharna mazhabi tehzeebon se phoota; yeh tareekh ka faisla hai, kisi ka propaganda nahi.

Continue Reading

Continue reading this article

Sign in free to read in full. Become a member to join the discussion without limits.

Sign in free to read →
Reader$0/mo
  • Read every article
  • Comment and reply (up to 100 words, 10/month)
  • Browse the community
  • Reader badge
Join as Reader
Scholar$8/mo
  • Everything in Writer
  • Scholar badge
  • Featured in the community
Join as Scholar