John Shaqi

Sikhism Se Mushkil Sawalat: Aman Se Talwar Tak, Aur Barabari Ka Adhoora Safar

Jis deen ka aghaz "na koi Hindu, na koi Musalman" se hua, us se sawal: kya us ne apni aik nayi taqseem to nahi banai? Nanak ki bansuri Gobind Singh ki talwar tak kaise pahunchi? Aur jo riwayat zaat-pat ko radd karti hai, us ke apne gurdware zaat par kyun bante hain? Sawalat — ehtiram aur mohabbat ke saath.

ByJohn Shaqi· July 2, 2026· 10 min read

Sikhism se sawal poochna aik lihaz se sab se mushkil hai: yeh riwayat itni jawan hai ke us ke zakhm abhi taza hain — 1947 bhi yaad hai, 1984 bhi. Magar isi liye zaroori bhi hai: jo sawal purane mazahib se sadiyon ki narmi ke saath poochhe ja sakte hain, wo yahan zinda logon ke seenon se guzarte hain. Hum poochenge — kyunke Nanak khud poochne wala tha. Us ne Makkah mein, riwayat ke mutabiq, apne pair Kaaba ki taraf kiye, aur jab qazi ne dant kar poocha, to jawab diya: "To mere pair us taraf kar do jahan Khuda nahi." Sawal se badi ibadat us riwayat mein koi nahi jis ka bani yeh jawab de sakta tha.

1. Bansuri Se Talwar Tak

Guru Nanak zulm ke saamne bhi geet gaata tha. Daswein Guru ne Khalsa ko talwar di. Do sadiyon ke andar aman ka deen aik martial qaum ban gaya. Kya hua?

Continue Reading

Continue reading this article

Sign in free to read in full. Become a member to join the discussion without limits.

Sign in free to read →
Reader$0/mo
  • Read every article
  • Comment and reply (up to 100 words, 10/month)
  • Browse the community
  • Reader badge
Join as Reader
Scholar$8/mo
  • Everything in Writer
  • Scholar badge
  • Featured in the community
Join as Scholar