These sentiments are familiar to those acquainted with the art and
writings of Mr. Craig, but it is indeed interesting to find somewhat
similar ideas expressed in the delightful but “different” manner
of a most eminent contemporary, Mr. G. Bernard Shaw. In a letter
concerning the puppets of his acquaintance, Mr. Shaw has written: “In
my youth (say 1865–75) there was a permanent exhibition in Dublin, the
proprietor of which was known as Mons Dark, which is Irish for Monsieur
d’Arc. From that show I learned that marionettes can produce a much
stronger illusion than bad actors can; and I have often suggested that
the Academy of Dramatic Art here try to obtain a marionette performance
to teach the students that very important part of the art of acting
which consists of not acting: that is, allowing the imagination of the
spectator to do its lion’s share of the work.”
Aside, however, from this not insignificant value as an example to
the actor of the future, the marionette has a positive and individual
contribution to make in the field of drama, a contribution which
the marionette alone can provide. There seem to be certain types
of plays more advantageously presented by puppets or shadows than
by human beings. These little creatures of wood or cardboard have
naturally that “sense of being beyond reality” which, according to
John Balance, “permeates all good art.” There is an article in the
_Hyperion, 1909_, by Franz Blei, critic and aesthete. He states: “I
believe there will always be certain dramatic poetry whose beauty
can be more significantly and effectively revealed by shadows than
by living actors. The shadow play will supplement the theatre of
living actors on one side as the marionette stage already does on the
other, in Paul Brann’s very brilliant productions, for example. With
shadows, the forcefulness of the verse and the emotional element is
very much heightened in effect; with marionettes the significance of
the action is intensified to a far greater degree than is attainable
by human beings, a point to which H. V. Kleist has already drawn
attention in praise of marionettes. With shadow plays, as with puppet
performances, the readers should not be professional actors, for their
very way of speaking invariably mimics the mannerisms of the man. The
limited movements of the shadows, however, suffer from this and also
the gestures of the marionettes which have a wider range but which
do not in the least resemble the customary stage gestures. Talented
dilettantes with good taste are more apt to strike the right note. I
fancy that the shadows and marionettes might please some people who had
not visited the theatre for quite a while, because they were unwilling
to waste their time on highly lifelike but utterly lifeless theatrical
productions.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account