A Budget of Paradoxes, Volume IIDe Morgan, Augustus
Philosophy
A Budget of Paradoxes, Volume II
De Morgan, Augustus
Circle-squaring; Perpetual motion; Science -- Miscellanea; Trisection of angle
[psi]z being (a/z)([phi](z+1)/[phi]z); of which observe that it diminishes
without limit as z increases without limit. Accordingly, we have
[psi]z = a/z+ [psi](z+1) = a/z+ a/(z+1)+ [psi](z+2)
= a/z+ a/(z+1)+ a/(z+2)+ [psi](z+3), etc.
And, [psi](z + n) diminishing without limit, we have
a/z . [phi](z+1)/[phi]z = (a/z+) (a/(z+1)+) (a/(z+2)+) (a/((z+3)+ ...))
Let z = 1/2; and let 4a = -x^2. Then (a/z)[phi](z+1) is -(x^2/2) ( 1 -
x^2/(2.3) + x^4/(2.3.4.5...)) or -(x/2) sin x. Again [phi]z is 1 - x^2/2 +
x^4/(2.3.4) or cos x: and the continued fraction is
(1/4)x^2/(1/2)+ (1/4)x^2/(3/2)+ (1/4)x^2/(5/2)+ ...
or -x/2 x/1+ -x^2/3+ -x^2/5+
...
{371} whence tan x = x/1+ -x^2/3+ -x^2/5+ -x^2/7+ ...
Or, as written in the usual way,
tan x = x
-------
1 - x^2
-------
3 - x^2
-------
5 - x^2
-------
7 - ...
This result may be proved in various ways: it may also be verified by
calculation. To do this, remember that if
a_1/b_1+ a_2/b_2+ a_3/b_3+ ... a_n/b_n = P_n/Q_n; then
P_1=a_1, P_2=b_2 P_1, P_3=b_3 P_2+a_3 P_1, P_4=b_4 P_3+a_4 P_2, etc.
Q_1=b_1, Q_2=b_2 Q_1+a_2, Q_3=b_3 Q_2+a_3 Q_1, Q_4=b_4 Q_3+a_4 Q_2, etc.
in the case before us we have
a_1=x, a_2=-x^2, a_3=-x^2, a_4=-x^2, a_5=-x^2, etc.
b_1=1, b_2=3, b_3=5, b_4=7, b_5=9, etc.
P_1=x Q_1=1
P_2=3x Q_2=3-x^2
P_3=15x-x^3 Q_3=15-6x^2
P_4=105x-10x^3 Q_4=105-45x^2+x^4
P_5=945x-105x^3+x^5 Q_5=945-420x^2+15x^4
P_6=10395x-1260x^3+21x^5 Q_6=10395-4725x^2+210x^4-x^6
We can use this algebraically, or arithmetically. If we divide P_n by Q_n,
we shall find a series agreeing with the known series for tan x, _as far
as_ n _terms_. That series is
x + x^3/3 + 2x^5/15 + 17x^7/315 + 62x^9/2835 + ...
{372} Take P_5, and divide it by Q_5 in the common way, and the first five
terms will be as here written. Now take _x_ = .1, which means that the
angle is to be one tenth of the actual unit, or, in degrees 5 deg..729578.
We find that when x = .1, P_6 = 1038.24021, Q_6 = 10347.770999; whence P_6
divided by Q_6 gives .1003346711. Now 5 deg..729578 is 5 deg.43'46-1/2";
and from the old tables of Rheticus[675]--no modern tables carry the
tangents so far--the tangent of this angle is .1003347670.
Now let x = (1/4)[pi]; in which case tan x = 1. If (1/4)[pi] be
commensurable with the unit, let it be (m/n), m and n being integers:
we know that (1/4)[pi] < 1. We have then
1=(m/n)/1- (m^2/n^2)/3- (m^2/n^2)/5- ... = m/n- m^2/3n- m^2/5n- m^2/7n-
...
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account