Sety carried out the erection of what is by far the most imposing
feature of the hall, the nave, with its double row of gigantic
open-flower columns, the largest in existence. Each of the twelve
tremendous columns is 69 feet in height and 33 feet in circumference,
while the spreading capitals, 11 feet in height, have an area large
enough for one hundred men to stand upon. Imagine twelve versions of
the Trajan Column at Rome, or the Vendôme Column at Paris, facing
one another in two rows and supporting gigantic architraves of sixty
to a hundred tons in weight, which in their turn support the great
roofing-slabs. These form the central avenue of the great hall. On
either side of them the papyrus-bud columns of the two side aisles rise
to a height of 42½ feet. The rows nearest to the central avenue on
either side bear above their architraves rectangular pillars which make
up the difference between the height of the side columns and those of
the centre, and which bear the extremities of the roof of the nave with
its cornice. On the lower level of the side pillars, the roof of the
hall continues over the rest of the area, supported by a forest of one
hundred and twenty-two columns.
Sety I is responsible for the whole of the northern half of the hall,
as well as for the central avenue, so that the southern portion of the
building is all that Ramses II can claim as his work, if indeed even
this part was not erected by his father, and only sculptured by him.
Ramses II, however, had the knack of securing to himself the glory
of work which was done by other men, and to most people the great
Hypostyle Hall of Karnak is his work, though he had really very little
to do with it.
The architectural merits of the huge building are undoubted, up to a
certain point; but its faults are equally unquestionable. Mere size
tells here, as indeed it almost always does, unless its impression
is spoilt by sheer incapacity. There can be no question of the
impressiveness of the great building. The central avenue, with its
soaring columns, and its grated clerestory rising above the roofs
of the side-aisles, is the prototype of all subsequent cathedral
architecture. But the side-aisles do not add to the dignity of the
great chamber. Their forest of squat, shapeless columns, instead of
being impressive, is only bewildering. Here, very certainly, you cannot
see the wood for the trees, and the spaciousness of the hall is quite
destroyed by the multitude of the supports of its roof. “The size that
strikes us,” says Professor Petrie, “is not the grandeur of strength,
but the bulkiness of disease.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account