A cityless and countryless world : $b An outline of practical cooperative individualismOlerich, Henry
Science
A cityless and countryless world : $b An outline of practical cooperative individualism
Olerich, Henry
Cooperation; Social problems -- Miscellanea
“But the evil training of your youths does not end here. For example:
Nearly all your parents, teachers, preachers and other persons take the
part of a child complaining against the conduct of another child. This
is one of the most unholy lessons you can teach. Let me illustrate my
meaning more clearly. A number of children are playing outdoors. One
strikes or otherwise offends another. The offended one will begin to
bawl in order to attract the attention of the mother in the house, or
it will go to the mother to state its actual or imaginary grievances.
The mother, who, as a rule, knows very little about human nature,
immediately loses her temper and plays general havoc with the real or
supposed offender; first, by asking him a series of questions which
tend to make a liar out of the child, and secondly, by beating the
offender, which act makes a worse despot out of the mother than the
offending child was. But remember that this is not all the harmful
results brought about by your method on this point. If, during the
inquiry, the child believes it can escape further punishment by telling
a falsehood, nine times out of ten it is tempted to do so, in order to
get out of its predicament. Thus it becomes plain that the mother’s
course of action offers a premium on lying.”
“But what would you do with such an offender?” asked Rev. Dudley.
“Would you let one child pound and abuse another without interfering?
Would you let your neighbor’s child kick and beat your own?”
“Let me explain, Rev. Dudley,” said Mr. Midith. “My reply to the first
part of your interrogatory is that I would change the _conditions_
which produce such offenders. Then you ask, ‘Would you let one child
pound and otherwise abuse another child, perhaps a younger one, without
interfering?’ My reply to that is, that your very interfering made
the _one_ child a ‘pounder,’ as you call him, and the other one a
whining complainer. If your adults would not resort to ‘pounding,’ your
children would not. Your children are only imitating your example. What
a prominent part in the mind of the child the rod plays in domestic
life is demonstrated by the fact that whenever your children play
house, the child who represents the father or mother is generally
applying the switch to the others. From what I have seen, I believe
that your children are not half as cruel in many respects as your
adults are.
“If you would never give any encouragement or attention to a
complaining tattler, there would be no such tattlers and complainers.
It is the encouragement and success with which the complainer meets at
your hands which make him a complainer, and the greater his success the
more frequently he will resort to it.
“A child, in order to become the completest person, must, from the
beginning, be left free to adjust its own social affairs. All parental
and governmental interference and paternalism is a hindrance in the
process of attaining the highest social plane.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account