A Civic Biology, Presented in ProblemsHunter, George W. (George William)
Science
A Civic Biology, Presented in Problems
Hunter, George W. (George William)
Biology; Sanitation
"The laboratory method was such an emancipation from the
old-time bookish slavery of pre-laboratory days that we may
have been inclined to overdo it and to subject ourselves to
a new slavery. It should never be forgotten that the
laboratory is simply a means to the end; that the dominant
thing should be a consistent chain of ideas which the
laboratory may serve to elucidate. When, however, the
laboratory assumes the first place and other phases of the
course are made explanatory to it, we have taken, in my
mind, an attitude fundamentally wrong. The question is, not
what _types_ may be taken up in the laboratory to be fitted
into the general scheme afterwards, but what _ideas_ are
most worth while to be worked out and developed in the
laboratory, if that happens to be the best way of doing it,
or if not, some other way to be adopted with perfect
freedom. Too often our course of study of an animal or plant
takes the easiest rather than the most illuminating path.
What is easier, for instance, particularly with large
classes of restless pupils who apparently need to be kept in
a condition of uniform occupation, than to kill a supply of
animals, preferably as near alike as possible, and set the
pupils to work drawing the dead remains? This method is
usually supplemented by a series of questions concerning the
remains which are sure to keep the pupils busy a while
longer, perhaps until the bell strikes, and which usually
are so planned as to anticipate any ideas that might
naturally crop up in the pupil's mind during the drawing
exercise.
"Such an abuse of the laboratory idea is all wrong and
should be avoided. The ideal laboratory ought to be a
retreat for rainy days; a substitute for out of doors; a
clearing house of ideas brought in from the outside. Any
course in biology which can be confined within four walls,
even if these walls be of a modern, well-equipped
laboratory, is in some measure a failure. Living things, to
be appreciated and correctly interpreted, must be seen and
studied in the open where they will be encountered
throughout life. _The place where an animal or plant is
found is just as important a characteristic as its shape or
function._ Impossible field excursions with large classes
within school hours, which only bring confusion to
_inflexible_ school programs, are not necessary to
accomplish this result. Properly administered, it is without
doubt one of our most efficient devices for developing
biological ideas, but the laboratory should be kept in its
proper relation to the other means at our disposal and never
be allowed to degenerate either into a place for vacuous
drawing exercises or a biological morgue where dead remains
are viewed."--_Dr. H. E. Walter._
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account