A Class Room Logic: Deductive and Inductive, with Special Application to the Science and Art of TeachingMcNair, George Hastings
Philosophy
A Class Room Logic: Deductive and Inductive, with Special Application to the Science and Art of Teaching
McNair, George Hastings
Logic
(14) Explain and exemplify the fallacies of composition and division.
(15) Illustrate the fallacy of figure of speech.
(16) Give reasons for denominating the fallacies in thought as
fallacies also of assumption.
(17) Define and illustrate the fallacies of accident and converse
accident.
(18) Distinguish between the fallacies of composition and division and
the two fallacies of accident.
(19) “Every rule has its exception,” what has this to do with the
fallacies of accident?
(20) Explain and illustrate the fallacy of irrelevant conclusion.
(21) Name the various ways in which irrelevant conclusion may be
committed.
(22) Illustrate the fallacy of _non sequitur_.
(23) Explain the fallacy of false cause.
(24) Give examples of the complex question.
(25) How may the teacher use the complex question to advantage?
(26) Explain the fallacy of begging the question.
(27) Illustrate the three forms of begging the question.
(28) From the viewpoint of form and meaning, test the validity of the
following:
(1) “No soldiers should be brought into the field who are not
well qualified to perform their part; none but veterans are
well qualified to perform their part, therefore, none but
veterans should be brought into the field.” Whately.
(2) “For the proverb is true, ‘That light gains make heavy
purses;’ for light gains come thick, whereas great gains come
but now and then.” Bacon.
(3) “Whatever is given on the evidence of sense may be taken as a
fact; the existence of God, therefore, is not a fact, for it
is not evident to sense.” St. Andrew. 1896.
(4) “All the trees in the park make a thick shade; this is one of
them, therefore this tree makes a thick shade.” Jevons.
(5) “What we eat grew in the field; loaves of bread are what we
eat; therefore loaves of bread grew in the fields.” Jevons.
(6) “Who is most hungry eats most; who eats least is most hungry;
therefore who eats least eats most.” Jevons.
(7) “Great talkers should be cropped, for they have no need of
ears.” Franklin.
(8) “Love your enemies, for they tell you your faults.” Franklin.
(9) “All the works of Shakespeare cannot be read in a day;
therefore the play of Hamlet, being one of the works of
Shakespeare, cannot be read in a day.” Jevons.
(10) “Logic as it was cultivated by the schoolmen proved a
fruitless study; therefore logic as it is cultivated at the
present day must be a fruitless study likewise.” Jevons.
=12. QUESTIONS FOR ORIGINAL THOUGHT AND INVESTIGATION.=
(1) Is there any difference in content between error and fallacy?
Illustrate.
(2) In what ways do trusts indulge in sophisms?
(3) May the sophism be used conscientiously by the country doctor?
Explain.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account