A Class Room Logic: Deductive and Inductive, with Special Application to the Science and Art of TeachingMcNair, George Hastings
Philosophy
A Class Room Logic: Deductive and Inductive, with Special Application to the Science and Art of Teaching
McNair, George Hastings
Logic
=11. QUESTIONS FOR ORIGINAL THOUGHT AND INVESTIGATION.=
1. Which is the broader term, subject or object? Prove it.
2. If a term like _Caesar_ is given extension does it become a
general term? Why?
3. Using “man” as a member of each, arrange at least three different
series.
4. Why may it be said that a connotative term is _two_ dimensional?
5. Is there a word which has a broader extension than “being”? Why?
6. Prove that _youth_ has less intension than _human being_.
7. Devise a series of words in which the variation is proportional.
8. Advance arguments supporting the hypothesis that the term _John_
has neither extension nor intension.
9. Suggest arguments to prove that “George Washington” has both
extension and intension.
CHAPTER 6.
DEFINITION.
=1. IMPORTANCE.=
To be clear, cogent, concise and consistent is to be logical.
Reference has been made to a striking tendency on the part of writers
and speakers to use words loosely. It is a noticeable fact that
scholars generally aim to be profound rather than clear, philosophical
rather than pointed.
In the use of text books more or less pedagogical these are the common
complaints: “I don’t understand what he means” or “You have to read so
much to get so little.” This condition gives to the topic of definition
a prominence which cannot be overlooked by those who are seeking the
truth; because the definition is the clearest, briefest and altogether
the most satisfactory way of describing an idea. Likewise the habit
of defining any doubtful term reduces to a minimum the possibility of
misunderstanding.
The subject must appeal strongly to the instructor, as he, above all
others, should make his work stand for clearness, pointedness and
continuity.
=2. THE PREDICABLES.=
_A predicable is a term which can be affirmed or predicated of any
subject._ In the proposition, “A man is a rational animal,” the term
“rational animal” is a predicable, because it can be affirmed of the
subject _man_.
To gain a clear knowledge of the definition it is quite necessary
to understand the _five predicables_ which we shall consider in the
following order:
1. Genus.
2. Species.
3. Differentia (difference).
4. Property.
5. Accident.
(1) _Genus_ and (2) _Species_.
Genus and species are relative terms and can best be defined together.
_A genus is a term which stands for two or more subordinate classes._
_A species is a term which represents one of the subordinate classes._
The genus may be subdivided into species; the species together form the
genus.
To illustrate: The term _man_ stands for five subordinate classes or
species, as white, black, brown, yellow and red. “Man” is, therefore,
a genus, while “white man” and “black man,” etc., are species. The
term “polygon” is a genus with reference to “trigon,” “tetragon,”
“pentagon,” etc., while “trigon” is a species of “polygon.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account