A Critique of the Theory of EvolutionMorgan, Thomas Hunt
Science
A Critique of the Theory of Evolution
Morgan, Thomas Hunt
Evolution
A great deal might be said in this connection. What is essential may be
said in a few words. Biology had been, and is still, largely a descriptive
and speculative science. _Mendel showed by experimental proof that heredity
could be explained by a simple mechanism. His discovery has been
exceedingly fruitful._
Science begins with naïve, often mystic conceptions of its problems. It
reaches its goal whenever it can replace its early guessing by verifiable
hypotheses and predictable results. This is what Mendel's law did for
heredity.
MENDEL'S FIRST DISCOVERY--SEGREGATION
[Illustration: FIG. 13. Diagram illustrating a cross between a red (dark)
and a white variety of four o'clock (Mirabilis jalapa).]
Let us turn to the demonstration of his first law--the law of segregation.
The first case I choose is not the one given by Mendel but one worked out
later by Correns. If the common garden plant called four o'clock (Mirabilis
jalapa) with red flowers is crossed to one having white flowers, the
offspring are pink (fig. 13). The hybrid, then, is intermediate in the
color of its flowers between the two parents. If these hybrids are inbred
the offspring are white, pink and red, in the proportion of 1:2:1. All of
these had the same ancestry, yet they are of three different kinds. If we
did not know their history it would be quite impossible to state what the
ancestry of the white or of the red had been, for they might just as well
have come from pure white and pure red ancestors respectively as to have
emerged from the pink hybrids. Moreover, when we test them we find that
they are as pure as are white or red flowering plants that have had all
white or all red flowering ancestors.
Mendel's Law explains the results of this cross as shown in figure 14.
The egg cell from the white parent carries the factor for white, the pollen
cell from the red parent carries the factor for red. The hybrid formed by
their union carries both factors. The result of their combined action is to
produce flowers intermediate in color.
When the hybrids mature and their germ cells (eggs or pollen) ripen, each
carries only one of these factors, either the red or the white, but not
both. In other words, the two factors that have been brought together in
the hybrid separate in its germ cells. Half of the egg cells are white
bearing, half red bearing. Half of the pollen cells are white bearing, half
red bearing. Chance combinations at fertilization give the three classes of
individuals of the second generation.
[Illustration: FIG. 14. Diagram illustrating the history of the factors in
the germ cells of the cross shown in Fig. 13.]
The white flowering plants should forever breed true, as in fact they do.
The red flowering plants also breed true. The pink flowering plants, having
the same composition as the hybrids of the first generation, should give
the same kind of result. They do, indeed, give this result i.e. one white
to two pink to one red flowered offspring.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account