A Critique of the Theory of EvolutionMorgan, Thomas Hunt
Science
A Critique of the Theory of Evolution
Morgan, Thomas Hunt
Evolution
In the case of eosin eye color no such process as that postulated by Darwin
to account for the differences between the sexes was involved; for the
single mutation that brought about the change also brought in the
dimorphism with it.
In recent years zoölogists have carefully studied several cases in which
two types of female are found in the same species. In the common clover
butterfly, there is a yellow and a white type of female, while the male is
yellow (fig. 26). It has been shown that a single factor difference
determines whether the female is yellow or white. The inheritance is,
according to Gerould, strictly Mendelian.
[Illustration: FIG. 27. Papilio turnus with two types of females above and
one type of male below.]
In Papilio turnus there exist, in the southern states, two kinds of
females, one yellow like the male, one black (fig. 27). The evidence here
is not so certain, but it seems probable that a single factor difference
determines whether the female shall be yellow or black.
Finally in Papilio polytes of Ceylon and India three different types of
females appear, (fig. 28 to right) only one of which is like the male. Here
the analysis of the breeding data shows the possibility of explaining this
case as due to two pairs Mendelian factors which give in combination the
three types of female.
[Illustration: FIG. 28. Papilio polytes, with three types of female to
right and one type of male above to left.]
Taking these cases together, they furnish a much simpler explanation than
the one proposed by Darwin. They show also that characters like these shown
by wild species may follow Mendel's law.
[Illustration: FIG. 29. Mutant race of fruit fly with intercalated
duplicate mesothorax on dorsal side.]
There has appeared in our cultures a fly in which the third division of the
thorax with its appendages has changed into a segment like the second (fig.
29). It is smaller than the normal mesothorax and its wings are imperfectly
developed, but the bristles on the upper surface may have the typical
arrangement of the normal mesothorax. The mutant shows how great a change
may result from a single factor difference.
A factor that causes duplication in the legs has also been found. Here the
interesting fact was discovered (Hoge) that duplication takes place only in
the cold. At ordinary temperatures the legs are normal.
[Illustration: FIG. 30. Mutant race of fruit fly, called eyeless; a, a'
normal eye.]
In contrast to the last case, where a character is doubled, is the next one
in which the eyes are lost (fig. 30). This change also took place at a
single step. All the flies of this stock however, cannot be said to be
eyeless, since many of them show pieces of the eye--indeed the variation is
so wide that the eye may even appear like a normal eye unless carefully
examined. Formerly we were taught that eyeless animals arose in caves. This
case shows that they may also arise suddenly in glass milk bottles, by a
change in a single factor.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account