A Critique of the Theory of EvolutionMorgan, Thomas Hunt
Science
A Critique of the Theory of Evolution
Morgan, Thomas Hunt
Evolution
When, then, these two F_1 flies (second row) are inbred the following
combinations are expected. Each egg will contain a black X (red eye
producing) or a white X (white eye producing) after the polar bodies have
been extruded. The male will produce two kinds of sperms, of which the
female producing will contain a black X (red eye producing). Since any egg
may by chance be fertilized by any sperm there will result the four classes
of individuals shown on the bottom row of the diagram. All the females will
have red eyes, because irrespective of the two kinds of eggs involved all
the female-producing sperm carry a black X. Half of the males have red eyes
because half of the eggs have had each a red-producing X chromosome. The
other half of the males have white eyes, because the other half of the eggs
had each a white-producing X chromosome. Other evidence has shown that the
Y chromosome of the male is indifferent, so far as these Mendelian factors
are concerned.
[Illustration: FIG. 59. Cross between red eyed male and white eyed female;
reciprocal cross of Fig. 58.]
The reciprocal experiment is illustrated in figure 59. A white eyed female
is mated to a red eyed male (top row). All the mature eggs of such a female
contain one white-producing X chromosome represented by the open bar in the
diagram. The red eyed male contains female-producing X-bearing sperm that
carry the factor for red eye color, and male-producing Y chromosomes. Any
egg fertilized by an X-bearing sperm will become a red eyed female because
the X chromosome that comes from the father carries the dominant factor for
red eye color. Any egg fertilized by a Y-bearing sperm will become a male
with white eyes because the only X chromosome that the male contains comes
from his mother and is white producing.
When these two F_1 flies are inbred (middle row) the following combinations
are expected. Half the eggs will contain each a white producing X
chromosome and half red producing. The female-producing sperms will each
contain a white X and the male-producing sperms will each contain an
indifferent Y chromosome. Chance meetings of egg and sperm will give the
four F_2 classes (bottom row). These consist of white eyed and red eyed
females and white eyed and red eyed males. The ratio here is 1:1 and not
three to one (3:1) as in other Mendelian cases. But Mendel's law of
segregation is not transgressed, as the preceding analysis has shown; for,
the chromosomes have followed strictly the course laid down on Mendel's
principle for the distribution of factors. The peculiar result in this case
is due to the fact that the F_1 male gets his single factor for eye color
from his mother only and it is linked to or contained in a body (the X
chromosome) that is involved in producing the females, while the mate of
this body--the Y chromosome--is indifferent with regard to these factors,
yet active as a mate to X in synapsis.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account