A Critique of the Theory of EvolutionMorgan, Thomas Hunt
Science
A Critique of the Theory of Evolution
Morgan, Thomas Hunt
Evolution
Because we can often arrange the series of structures in a line extending
from the very simple to the more complex, we are apt to become unduly
impressed by this fact and conclude that if we found the complete series we
should find all the intermediate steps and that they have arisen in the
order of their complexity. This conclusion is not necessarily correct. Let
me give some examples that have come under my own observation. We have bred
for five years the wild fruit fly Drosophila ampelophila (fig. 4) and we
have found over a hundred and twenty-five new types that breed true. Each
has arisen independently and suddenly. Every part of the body has been
affected by one or another of these mutations. For instance many different
kinds of changes have taken place in the wings and several of these involve
the size of the wings. If we arrange the latter arbitrarily in the order of
their size there will be an almost complete series beginning with the
normal wings and ending with those of apterous flies. Several of these
types are represented in figure 5. The order in which these mutations
occurred bears no relation to their size; each originated independently
from the wild type.
[Illustration: FIG. 5. Mutants of Drosophila ampelophila arranged in order
of size of wings: (a) cut; (b) beaded; (c) stumpy; (d) another individual
of stumpy; (f) vestigial (g) apterous.]
The wings of the wild fly are straight (fig. 4). Several types have arisen
in which the wings are bent upwards and in the most extreme type the wings
are curled over the back, as seen in figure 54 (g), yet there is no
historical connection between these stages.
Mutations have occurred involving the pigmentation of the body and wings.
The head and thorax of the wild Drosophila ampelophila are grayish yellow,
the abdomen is banded with yellow and black, and the wings are gray. There
have appeared in our cultures several kinds of darker types ranging to
almost black flies (fig. 20) and to lighter types that are quite yellow. If
put in line a series may be made from the darkest flies at one end to the
light yellow flies at the other. These types, with the fluctuations that
occur within each type, furnish a complete series of gradations; yet
historically they have arisen independently of each other.
Many changes in eye color have appeared. As many as thirty or more races
differing in eye color are now maintained in our cultures. Some of them are
so similar that they can scarcely be separated from each other. It is
easily possible beginning with the darkest eye color, sepia, which is deep
brown, to pick out a perfectly graded series ending with pure white eyes.
But such a serial arrangement would give a totally false idea of the way
the different types have arisen; and any conclusion based on the existence
of such a series might very well be entirely erroneous, for the fact that
such a series exists bears no relation to the order in which its members
have appeared.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account