A History of Matrimonial Institutions, Vol. 1 of 3Howard, George Elliott
History
A History of Matrimonial Institutions, Vol. 1 of 3
Howard, George Elliott
Families; Marriage -- History
[234] _Studies in Ancient History_, I, viii, 83-146. McLennan's
views are somewhat modified and further developed in his
_Patriarchal Theory_, notably in chaps. xii and xiii, 181-242;
and a mass of new material is presented in his _Studies_, 2d ser.
(1896).
[235] In his two earlier works McLennan is vague as to the exact
meaning of "promiscuity" and "polyandry;" but in his letter to
Darwin (1874), _Studies_, II, 50-56, he defines these terms, so
that, in effect, he makes important concessions to the adherents
of early monogamy and polygyny and to those critics who have
questioned his theory of universal phases of progress. He says,
referring to the first series of _Studies_: "The import of my
reasoning is that more or less of it [promiscuity] and of
_indifference_ must appear in the hordes or their sections or
some of them." It is used to "denote the general conduct as to
sexual matters of men without wives.... Now I agree with you
that from what we know of human nature we may be sure that each
man would aim at having one or more women to himself, and cases
would occur wherein for a longer or shorter time the aim would
be realized, and there would be instances of what we may call
polygyny and monogamy--your first stage.... I take it, polygyny,
monogamy, and polyandry (or its equivalents) must have occurred
in every district from the first;" but the cases of polyandry
would be much more numerous. "Polyandry, in my view, is an
advance _from_, and _contraction_ of, promiscuity. It gives men
wives. Till men have wives they may have tastes, but they have
no obligations in matters of sex. You may be sure polygyny in
the early stage never had the sanction of _group opinion_." This
late explanation does not, however, relieve the author from
responsibility for the misleading statements or obscurities of
his earlier works. _Cf._ the rather too appreciative review of
the second series of _Studies_ by PROFESSOR GIDDINGS, in
_Annals of the Am. Academy_, IV, 97-100.
[236] _Studies_, I, 83, 88-90.
[237] _Ibid._, chap. viii.
[238] On the three systems of kinship see POST,
_Familienrecht_, 6 ff.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account