A history of the Irish poor law, in connexion with the condition of the peopleNicholls, George, Sir
History
A history of the Irish poor law, in connexion with the condition of the people
Nicholls, George, Sir
Poor laws -- Ireland -- History
poor-law, under circumstances similar to those now existing in
Donegal; and believe that such a law, whilst it provides for the
relief of the destitute, will be a safeguard to property, and
facilitate the introduction of other ameliorations.
_There ought to be a law of Settlement._—“There is no part of the
subject to which I have given more attention than to the question of
settlement. Of the evils arising from settlement in England, there
can be no doubt, and the grounds on which it was proposed to
establish a poor-law in Ireland without settlement, are explained in
my former Report. But it appears that many persons still consider
some law of settlement necessary for securing local co-operation
based upon local interests, for the protection of particular unions
from undue pressure, and for guarding the towns on the eastern coast
from being burdened with the destitute who may flock thither, or be
sent thither from England or Scotland, or with the families of the
large body of migrants who proceed to Great Britain in the harvest
season and return at its conclusion. If there were danger from all
or any of these sources, it might be right to make provision against
it in the bill; but I am satisfied that, in carrying out the measure
as now proposed, none of these inconveniences would arise, beyond
what the commissioners could meet by special regulations, without
recurring to a settlement law. There is this primary objection to
settlement, that it impedes the free distribution of labour, and
interferes with the fair and open competition which is alike
necessary for protecting the employer and the employed, and by which
an equalisation of supply and demand in the labour-market can alone
be maintained. Its direct tendency is to depress the social
condition and character of the people; for by narrowing the field of
labour, and binding individuals to a particular locality, not
perhaps favourable to the development or most profitable employment
of their faculties, improvement is checked, independence is
destroyed, and the working classes, without resource or elasticity
of spirit, are led to depend upon their place of settlement in every
contingency, instead of upon themselves. If therefore the bill as at
present proposed, by requiring the rate to be levied upon the union
for relief of the actually destitute within it is sufficient, as I
believe it to be, for securing attention to the business of the
union, there can be no necessity to establish a law of settlement
for such purpose; and nothing short of absolute necessity in that or
some other respect, could justify the introduction of a law, the
direct tendency of which would be in other respects so injurious.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account