A history of the Irish poor law, in connexion with the condition of the peopleNicholls, George, Sir
History
A history of the Irish poor law, in connexion with the condition of the people
Nicholls, George, Sir
Poor laws -- Ireland -- History
_The suppression of Mendicancy objected to._—“Objections have been made
to the vagrancy clauses, and it has been contended that if such
provisions were necessary, they should be established by a separate
Act. Whether the suppression of mendicancy be provided for in the
Poor Law Bill, or by a separate bill, does not seem very material;
but it is important that the provision should be made concurrently
with the Poor Law measure. To establish a poor-law, without at the
same time suppressing mendicancy, would be imperfect legislation,
especially with reference to the present condition of the Irish
people. It is true there are now vagrancy laws in Ireland, which
enact whipping, imprisonment, and transportation as the punishments
of mendicancy; but these laws are inoperative, partly from their
severity, and partly from other causes. Ireland wants a vagrancy law
that shall operate in unison with the Poor Law, for without such
concurrent action, both laws would be in a great measure
ineffective. The suppression of mendicancy is necessary for the
protection of the peasantry themselves. No Irish cottier, however
poor, closes his door whilst partaking of his humble meal. The
mendicant has free access, and is never refused a share. There is a
superstitious dread of bringing down the beggar’s curse, and thus
mendicancy is sustained in the midst of poverty, perpetuating itself
amongst its victims. Much of the feeling out of which this state of
things has arisen may, I think, be traced to the absence of any
provision for relieving the destitute. A mendicant solicits charity
on the plea of destitution. His plea must be admitted, for it cannot
be disproved; and to refuse relief, may occasion the death of a
fellow-creature, which would be a crime of great magnitude. Hence
the admission of the mendicant’s claim, which is regarded in the
light of an obligation by the Irish peasantry. To make provision for
relieving mendicants at the public charge, without at the same time
preventing the practice of begging, would leave the peasant exposed
to much of the pressure which he now sustains from this source; for
the mendicant class would generally prefer the vagrant life to which
they are accustomed, to the order and restraint of a workhouse. To
suppress mendicancy, is therefore necessary both as an adjunct of
the proposed Poor Law, and for the protection of the labouring
classes throughout Ireland.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account