A Letter to Grover Cleveland: On His False Inaugural Address, The Usurpations and Crimes of Lawmakers and Judges, and the Consequent Poverty, Ignorance, and Servitude Of The PeopleSpooner, Lysander
Philosophy
A Letter to Grover Cleveland: On His False Inaugural Address, The Usurpations and Crimes of Lawmakers and Judges, and the Consequent Poverty, Ignorance, and Servitude Of The People
Spooner, Lysander
Cleveland, Grover, 1837-1908; United States -- Politics and government
These statutes and reports are so far out of reach of the people at
large, that the only knowledge a man can ordinarily get of them, when he
is summoned before one of the tribunals appointed to execute them, is
to be obtained by employing an expert--or so-called lawyer--to enlighten
him.
This expert in injustice is one who buys these great volumes of statutes
and reports, and spends his life in studying them, and trying to keep
himself informed of their contents. But even he can give a client very
little information in regard to them; for the statutes and decisions are
so voluminous, and are so constantly being made and unmade, and are so
destitute of all conformity to those natural principles of justice which
men readily and intuitively comprehend; and are moreover capable of so
many different interpretations, that he is usually in as great
doubt--perhaps in even greater doubt--than his client, as to what will
be the result of a suit.
The most he can usually say to his client, is this:
Every civil suit must finally be given to one of two persons,
the plaintiff or defendant. Whether, therefore, your cause is a
just, or an unjust, one, you have at least one chance in two,
of gaining it. But no matter how just your cause may be, you
need have no hope that the tribunal that tries it, will be
governed by any such consideration, if the statute book, or the
past decisions of the supreme court, are against you. So, also,
no matter how unjust your cause may be, you may nevertheless
expect to gain it, if the statutes and past decisions are in
your favor. If, therefore, you have money to spend in such a
lottery as this, I will do my best to gain your cause for you,
whether it be a just, or an unjust, one.
If the charge is a criminal one, this expert says to his client:
You must either be found guilty, or acquitted. Whether,
therefore, you are really innocent or guilty, you have at least
one chance in two, of an acquittal. But no matter how innocent
you may be of any real crime, you need have no hope of an
acquittal, if the statute book, or the past decisions of the
supreme court, are against you. If, on the other hand, you have
committed a real wrong to another, there may be many laws on
the statute book, many precedents, and technicalities, and
whimsicalities, through which you may hope to escape. But your
reputation, your liberty, or perhaps your life, is at stake. To
save these you can afford to risk your money, even though the
result is so uncertain. Therefore you had best give me your
money, and I will do my best to save you, whether you are
innocent or guilty.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account