A Manual of Moral PhilosophyPeabody, Andrew P. (Andrew Preston)
Philosophy
A Manual of Moral Philosophy
Peabody, Andrew P. (Andrew Preston)
Ethics
5 The duty of society to inflict capital punishment on the murderer
has been maintained on the ground of the Divine command to that
effect, said to have been given to Noah, and thus to be binding on
all his posterity. (Genesis ix. 5.) My own belief—founded on a
careful examination of the Hebrew text—is, that the _human_ murderer
is not referred to in this precept, but that it simply requires the
slaying of the beast that should cause the death of a man,—a
precaution which was liable to be neglected in a rude state of
society, and was among the special enactments of the Mosaic law.
(Exodus xxi. 38.) If, however, the common interpretation be
retained, the precept requires the shedding of the murderer’s blood
by the _brother_ or nearest kinsman of the murdered man, and is not
obeyed by giving up the murderer to the _gallows_ and the _public
executioner_. Moreover, the same series of precepts prescribes an
abstinence from the natural juices of animal food, which would
require an entire revolution in our shambles, kitchens, and tables.
If these precepts were Divine commandments for men of all times,
they should be obeyed in full; but there is the grossest
inconsistency and absurdity in holding only a portion of one of them
sacred, and ignoring all the rest.
6 Latin, _virtus_, from _vir_, which denotes not, like _homo_, simply
a human being, but a man endowed with all appropriate manly
attributes, and comes from the same root with _vis_, strength. The
Greek synonyms of _virtus_, ἀρετή, is derived from Ἀρης, the god of
war, who in the heroic days of Greece was the ideal man, the
standard of human excellence, and whose name some lexicographers
regard—as it seems to me, somewhat fancifully—as allied through its
root to ἀνήρ, which bears about the same relation to ἄνθρωπος that
_vir_ bears to _homo_.
7 In the languages which have inherited or adopted the Latin _virtus_,
it retains its original signification, with one striking exception,
which yet is perhaps an exception in appearance rather than in
reality. In the Italian, virtu is employed to signify taste, and
_virtuoso_, which may denote a virtuous man, oftener means a
collector of objects of taste. We have here an historical landmark.
There was a period when, under civil despotism, the old Roman
manhood had entirely died out on its native soil, while
ecclesiastical corruption rendered the nobler idea of Christian
manhood effete; and then the highest type of manhood that remained
was the culture of those refined sensibilities, those ornamental
arts, and that keen sense of the beautiful, in which Italy as far
surpassed other lands, as it was for centuries inferior to them in
physical bravery and in moral rectitude.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account