A Moslem seeker after God : $b showing Islam at its best in the life and teaching of al-Ghazali, mystic and theologian of the eleventh centuryZwemer, Samuel Marinus
Philosophy
A Moslem seeker after God : $b showing Islam at its best in the life and teaching of al-Ghazali, mystic and theologian of the eleventh century
Zwemer, Samuel Marinus
Ghazzali, 1058-1111
One section of the _Ihya_ (Vol. III, p. 96 ff.) deals with the question
as to when lies are justifiable, and clearly shows that according to
Al-Ghazali, in the realm of truth at least, the end justifies the means.
“Know,” he says, “that a lie is not _haram_ (wrong) in itself, but only
because of the evil conclusions to which it leads the hearer, making
him believe something that is not really the case. Ignorance sometimes
is an advantage, and if a lie causes this kind of ignorance it may be
allowed. It is sometimes a duty to lie. Maimun Ibn Muhran said, ‘A lie
is sometimes better than truth: for instance, if you see a man seeking
for another in order to kill him, what do you reply to the question as to
where he is? Of course you will reply thus, for such a lie is lawful. We
say that the end justifies the means.’
“If lying and truth both lead to a good result, you must tell the truth,
for a lie is forbidden in this case. If a lie is the only way to reach a
good result, it is allowable (_hallal_). A lie is lawful when it is the
only path to duty. For example, if a Moslem flees from an unjust one and
you are asked about him, you are obliged to lie in order to save him.
If the outcome of war, reconciliation between two separated friends, or
the safety of an oppressed depends on a lie, then a lie is allowed. In
all cases we must be careful not to lie when there is no necessity for
it, lest it be _haram_ (wrong). If a wicked person asks a man about his
wealth he has to deny having any; and so if a sultan asks a man about a
crime he has committed, he has to deny it and say, ‘I have not stolen,’
when he did steal; ‘nor done any vice,’ when he has done. The Prophet
said, ‘He who has done a shameful deed must conceal it, for revealing one
disgrace is another disgrace.’ A person must deny the sins of others as
well. Making peace between wives is a duty, even by pretending to each of
them that she is loved the most, and by making promises to please her.
“We must lie when truth leads to unpleasant results, but tell the truth
when it leads to good results. Lying for one’s pleasure, or for increase
of wealth, or for fame is forbidden. One wife must not lie for her
husband to tease another wife. Lying is allowed in persuading children to
go to school; also false promises and false threats.”
We get another view of Al-Ghazali’s ethics in his teaching regarding
education. There is a special section in the _Ihya_ (Vol. III, p. 53)
which deals with the education of boys and the improvement of their
morals. It is not surprising that nothing is said as regards the
education of girls, for even now many Moslem authorities consider it
inadvisable that they should be taught to read and write. The chapter
referred to begins as follows:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account