And here is the whole point on which the process depends. We can tell
where each cube would come, but we do not _know_ the block in this new
position. I draw a distinction between the two acts, “to tell where it
would be,” and to “know.” Telling where it would be is the preparation
for knowing. The power of assigning the positions may be called the
theory of the block. The actual knowledge is got by carrying out the
theory practically, by putting up the blocks and becoming able to
realize without effort where each one is.
It is not enough to put up the model blocks in the reverse position. It
is found that this up and down is a very obstinate element indeed, and a
good deal of work is requisite to get rid of it completely. But when it
is got rid of in one set of cubes, the faculty is formed of appreciating
shape independently of the particular parts which are above or below on
first examination. We discover in our own minds the faculty of
appreciating the facts of position independent of gravity and its
influence on us. I have found a very great difference in different minds
in this respect. To some it is easy, to some it is hard.
And to use our old instance, the discovery of this capacity is like the
discovery of a love of justice in the being who has forced himself to
act justly. It is a capacity for being able to take a view independent
of the conditions under which he is placed, and to feel in accordance
with that view. There is, so far as I know, no means of arriving
immediately at this impartial appreciation of shape. It can only be done
by, as it were, extending our own body so as to include certain cubes,
and appreciating then the relation of the other cubes to those. And
after this, by identifying ourselves with other cubes, and in turn
appreciating the relation of the other cubes to these. And the practical
putting up of the cubes is the way in which this power is gained. It
springs up with a repetition of the mechanical acts. Thus there are
three processes. 1st, An apprehension of what the position of the cubes
would be. 2nd, An actual putting of them up in accordance with that
apprehension, 3rd, The springing up in the mind of a direct feeling of
what the block is, independent of any particular presentation.
Thus the self element of up and down can be got rid of out of a block of
cubes.
And when even a little block is known like this, the mind has gained a
great deal.
Yet in the apprehension and knowledge of the block of cubes with the up
and down relation in them, there is more than in the absolute
apprehension of them. For there is the apprehension of their position
and also of the effect of gravity on them in their position.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account