A Problem in Greek Ethics: Being an inquiry into the phenomenon of sexual inversion, addressed especially to medical psychologists and jurists — John Shaqi
A Problem in Greek Ethics: Being an inquiry into the phenomenon of sexual inversion, addressed especially to medical psychologists and juristsSymonds, John Addington
Philosophy
A Problem in Greek Ethics: Being an inquiry into the phenomenon of sexual inversion, addressed especially to medical psychologists and jurists
Symonds, John Addington
Ethics -- Greece; Greece -- Social life and customs; Homosexuality
Resuming the results of the last four sections, we find two separate
forms of masculine passion clearly marked in early Hellas--a noble and a
base, a spiritual and a sensual. To the distinction between them the
Greek conscience was acutely sensitive; and this distinction, in theory
at least, subsisted throughout their history. They worshipped Erôs, as
they worshipped Aphrodite, under the twofold titles of Ouranios
(celestial) and Pandemos (vulgar, or _volvivaga_); and, while they
regarded the one love with the highest approval, as the source of
courage and greatness of soul, they never publicly approved the other.
It is true, as will appear in the sequel of this essay, that boy-love in
its grossest form was tolerated in historic Hellas with an indulgence
which it never found in any Christian country, while heroic comradeship
remained an ideal hard to realise, and scarcely possible beyond the
limits of the strictest Dorian sect. Yet the language of philosophers,
historians, poets and orators is unmistakable. All testify alike to the
discrimination between vulgar and heroic love in the Greek mind. I
purpose to devote a separate section of this inquiry to the
investigation of these ethical distinctions. For the present, a
quotation from one of the most eloquent of the later rhetoricians will
sufficiently set forth the contrast, which the Greek race never wholly
forgot:[8]--
"The one love is mad for pleasure; the other loves beauty. The one
is an involuntary sickness; the other is a sought enthusiasm. The
one tends to the good of the beloved; the other to the ruin of
both. The one is virtuous; the other incontinent in all its acts.
The one has its end in friendship; the other in hate. The one is
freely given; the other is bought and sold. The one brings praise;
the other blame. The one is Greek; the other is barbarous. The one
is virile; the other effeminate. The one is firm and constant; the
other light and variable. The man who loves the one love is a
friend of God, a friend of law, fulfilled of modesty, and free of
speech. He dares to court his friend in daylight, and rejoices in
his love. He wrestles with him in the playground and runs with him
in the race, goes afield with him to the hunt, and in battle fights
for glory at his side. In his misfortune he suffers, and at his
death he dies with him. He needs no gloom of night, no desert
place, for this society. The other lover is a foe to heaven, for he
is out of tune and criminal; a foe to law, for he transgresses law.
Cowardly, despairing, shameless, haunting the dusk, lurking in
desert places and secret dens, he would fain be never seen
consorting with his friend, but shuns the light of day, and follows
after night and darkness, which the shepherd hates, but the thief
loves."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account