There are many other similar passages which clearly prove that the class
of literature passing under the appelation of _Puranas_ and _Itihasas_
were in existence even in the Vedic period. From these statements it is
very difficult to arrive at a conclusion when these works were really
written. The various episodes of these works passed orally from one
generation to another for many centuries before they were committed to
writing. And even after this many interpelations had been added by
various writers in the shape of references to contemporaneous events.
The ancient Hindu writers were so very modest that they never liked the
idea of making their names known as authors. Many works written by those
unknown writers passed in the names of their Gurus or spiritual guides.
Thus from internal evidence it is not safe to make any attempt for the
determination of date or authorship. The only safe course is to give an
approximate date based upon the development of thought that is to be
seen in various works, making use of the internal evidence as a test for
the accuracy of our conclusions. Taking a survey of the various
departments of Hindu literature we find that the theory of incarnation
and sectarial worship were absolutely unknown to the Vedic writers and
took a very meagre proportion even when the Ramayana and the Mahabharata
were written. In the Puranas however we see that the entire theology is
based on the doctrine of incarnation-the various sects have their
rituals and ceremonies definitely laid down and the caste rules
introduced with all their severity and force. Besides we also find the
doctrines of Vedanta and Sankya explained popularly in the shape of
episodes. This clearly proves that whatever may be the actual date of
the composition of these works they are long posterior to the
Mahabharata and the Ramayana. From the evidence of style, the treatment
of subject matter, the account of Creation and Patriarchal families it
is clear, that Harivamsha, although it is a sequel to the Mahabharata,
was written long after that great work. If it was not written in the
same period when the Puranas were composed it was not at least written
earlier.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account