A Short History of Freethought Ancient and Modern, Volume 1 of 2: Third edition, Revised and Expanded, in two volumesRobertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Religion
A Short History of Freethought Ancient and Modern, Volume 1 of 2: Third edition, Revised and Expanded, in two volumes
Robertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Free thought -- History
There being thus no highly imagined "moral Eternal" in the
religion of primitive man, the Hebrews were originally in the
ordinary position. Their early practice of human sacrifice is
implied in the legend of Abraham and Isaac, and in the story of
Jephthah. (Cp. Micah vi, 7, and Kuenen on the passage, i, 237.) In
their reputed earliest prophetic books we find them addicted to
divination (Hosea iv, 12; Micah v, 12. Cp. the prohibition in
Lev. xx, 6; also 2 Kings xxiii, 24, and Isa. iii, 2; as to the
use of the ephod, teraphim, and urim and thummim, see Kuenen,
Relig. of Israel, Eng. tr. i, 97-100) and to polytheism. (Amos v,
26, viii, 14; Hosea i, 13, 17, etc. Cp. Jud. viii, 27; 1 Sam. vii,
3.) These things Mr. Lang seems to admit (p. 309, note), despite
his previous claim; but he builds (p. 332) on the fact that
the Hebrews showed little concern about a future state--that
"early Israel, having, so far as we know, a singular lack of
interest in the future of the soul, was born to give himself up
to developing, undisturbed, the theistic conception, the belief
in a righteous Eternal"--whereas later Greeks and Romans, like
Egyptians, were much concerned about life after death. Mr. Lang's
own general theory would really require that all peoples at a
certain stage should act like the Israelites; but he suspends it
in the interest of the orthodox view as to the early Hebrews. At
the same time he omits to explain why the Hebrews failed to
adopt the future-state creed when they were "contaminated"--a
proposition hardly reconcilable, on any view, with the sentence
just quoted. The solution, however, is simple. Israel was not
at all "singular" in the matter. The early (Homeric) Greeks
and Romans (cp. as to Hades the Iliad, passim; Odyssey, bk. xi,
passim; Tiele, Outlines, p. 209, as to the myth of Persephone;
and Preller, Römische Mythologie, ed. Köhler, 1865, pp. 452-55,
as to the early Romans), like the early Vedic Aryans (Tiele,
Outlines, p. 117; Müller, Anthropol. Relig. p. 269), and the
early Babylonians and Assyrians (Meyer, Gesch. des Alt. i, 181-82;
Sayce, Hib. Lect. p. 364) took little thought of a future state.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account