A Sixth-Century Fragment of the Letters of Pliny the Younger: A Study of Six Leaves of an Uncial Manuscript Preserved; in the Pierpont Morgan Library New YorkRand, Edward Kennard
General
A Sixth-Century Fragment of the Letters of Pliny the Younger: A Study of Six Leaves of an Uncial Manuscript Preserved; in the Pierpont Morgan Library New York
Rand, Edward Kennard
Manuscripts, Latin -- Facsimiles; Manuzio, Aldo, 1449 or 50-1515; Paleography, Latin; Pliny, the Younger -- Correspondence
[Footnote 59: See plate XVIII.]
[Sidenote: _Aldus and Budaeus compared_]
It is of some importance to consider what Budaeus might have done to the
text of Beroaldus had he treated it to a systematic collation with the
Parisinus. Our fragment allows us to test Budaeus; for even if it be not
the Parisinus itself, its readings with the help of _B_, _F_, and Aldus
show what was in that ancient book. I have enumerated above[60] eleven
readings of _ΠBF_ which are called errors by Keil, but of which nine
were accepted by Aldus and five by the latest editor, Professor Merrill.
In two of these (62, 33 and 64, 3), Budaeus, like Aldus, wisely does
not harbor an obvious error of _P_. In two more (62, 16 and 65, 12),
Beroaldus already has the reading of _P_. Of the remaining seven,
however, all of which Aldus adopted, there is no trace in Budaeus. There
are also nineteen cases of obvious error in the ς editions, which
Aldus corrected but Budaeus did not touch. I give the complete
apparatus[61] for these twenty-six places, as they will illustrate the
radical difference between Aldus and Budaeus in their use of the
Parisinus.
[Footnote 60: See above, p. 47.]
[Footnote 61: The readings of manuscripts are taken from Merrill,
those of the editions from Keil; in the latter case, I use
parentheses if the reading is only implied, not stated.]
60, 15 duplicia] _MVDrς_
duplicata _ΠBFGpa_
61, 12 confusa adhuc] _MVς_
adhuc confusa _ΠBFGpra_
18 milia passuum tria nec] _ΠBFMV_(_p_?)_a_
milia passum tria et nec _D_
mille pastria nec _r_
mille pas. nec _ς_
62, 6 doctissime] _MVς_
et doctissime _r_
doctissima _ΠBFDa_
et doctissima _p_
26 igitur eundem mihi cursum, eundem] _ΠBFD_(_p_?)_a_
igitur et eundem mihi cursum et eundem _rς_
fuit (25)--potes (64, 12) _om. MV_
63, 2 MAXIMO] _ΠBFDG_(_pr?_)_a_
Valerio Max. _ς_
Gauio Maximo _Catanaeus_
4 Arrianus Maturus] _ΠBFDra_
arianus maturus _Gp_
Arrianus Maturius _ς_
5 est] _ΠBFDG_(_p_?)_a_ _om. r Ber._
9 ardentibus dicere] _ΠBFDG_(_r_?)_a_
dicere ardentius _pς_
12 excolendusque] _ΠBFD_(_p_?)_a_
extollendusque _Grς_
15 conferas in eum] _ΠBFD_(_p_?)_a_
in eum conferas _Grς_
17 excipit] _ΠBFD_(_p_?)_a_
accipit _rς_
quam si] _ΠBFDG_(_p_?)_a_
quasi si _r_
quasi _Laet._, _Ber._
20 CORELLIAE HISPULLAE SUAE] CORELLIAE _ΠB_
AD CAERELLIAE HISPULLAE _ind. ΠB_
CORELLIE ISPULLAE _F_ CORELLIAE HISPULLAE _a_
corneliae (Coreliae _Catanaeus_) hispullae (suae _add. Do_)
_DGprς_
22 teque et] _DG_(_p_?)_[sigma]_
teque _ΠBFra_
23 et in] _ΠBFDG_(_p_?)_a_
et _rς_
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account