Skye, Island of (Scotland) -- Description and travel
the moon, the breeze mourning alone in the desert, the battles and
friendships of his far-off youth, and the flight of the "dark-brown
years." These poems are wonderful transcripts of Hebridean scenery.
They are as full of mists as the Hebridean glens themselves. Ossian
seeks his images in the vapoury wraiths. Take the following of two
chiefs parted by their king:--"They sink from their king on either
side, like two columns of morning mist when the sun rises between
them on his glittering rocks. Dark is their rolling on either side,
each towards its reedy pool." You cannot help admiring the image;
and I saw the misty circumstance this very morning when the kingly
sun struck the earth with his golden spear, and the cloven mists
rolled backwards to their pools like guilty things.
That a large body of poetical MSS. existed in the Highlands we know;
we know also that, when challenged to do so, Macpherson produced his
originals; and the question arises, Was Macpherson a competent and
faithful translator of these MSS.? Did he reproduce the original in
all its strength and sharpness? On the whole, perhaps Macpherson
translated the ancient Highland poems as faithfully as Pope
translated Homer, but his version is in many respects defective and
untrue. The English Ossian is Macpherson's, just as the most popular
English Iliad is Pope's. Macpherson was not a thoroughly-equipped
Gaelic scholar; his version is full of blunders and misapprehensions
of meaning, and he expressed himself in the fashionable poetic
verbiage of his day. You find echoes of Milton, Shakespeare, Pope,
and Dryden, and these echoes give his whole performance a hybrid
aspect. It has a particoloured look; is a thing of odds and ends, of
shreds and patches; in it antiquity and his own day are incongruously
mixed--like Macbeth in a periwig, or a ruin decked out with new and
garish banners. Here is Macpherson's version of a portion of the
third book of Fingal:--
"Fingal beheld the son of Starno: he remembered Agandecca. For
Swaran with the tears of youth had mourned his white-bosomed sister.
He sent Ullin of Songs to bid him to the feast of shells. For
pleasant on Fingal's soul returned the memory of the first of his
loves!
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account