Precisely similar to this is the error of those who for the most part
belong to the same school, and who attribute the essence of fever to a
morbid condition of the blood. The blood may be diseased in fever, but
if it be so, these writers do not _know_ it, or at least they do not
adduce any evidence that they are in possession of such knowledge: they
do not appear so much as to have questioned chemistry; at all events, it
is certain that they have hitherto received no satisfactory answer.
There is no evidence on record that the alleged determination of the
blood takes place in every type and every degree of fever: and if there
were it would still be but one event among many, and one that occurs
late in the series, and therefore could possibly be nothing more than an
effect.
In like manner those who maintain that inflammation of the brain is the
sole cause of fever, assume as an established and admitted fact the
universal and invariable existence of inflammation of the brain in this
disease. Inflammation of the brain, without doubt, is demonstrable of
many individual cases, and of some whole types: but beyond this there is
no proof that the generalization can be carried: the evidence indeed in
regard to many cases is entirely against the assumption, and is as
complete as negative evidence can well be: consequently it must be
admitted that even this hypothesis, in the present state of our
knowledge, is founded on the error of assigning to the whole genus what
belongs only to particular species: and it would be trifling with the
reader to attempt to prove, that this is still more certainly and
strikingly true with regard to inflammation of the mucous membrane of
the stomach and intestines—an affection which in innumerable cases in
which its existence is certain, clearly appears on the slightest
examination of the succession of events, to be an effect and not a
cause.
No comprehensive view can be taken of fever, no just conclusion can be
arrived at relative to its nature and seat until it be studied with a
consciousness of the liability to such errors and a vigilant endeavour
to avoid them. The present investigation has been undertaken with a deep
consciousness of the danger and a watchful and unremitting care to avoid
it. Even if the effort prove to be without success, the example can
scarcely remain without use.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account