A True Account of the Battle of Jutland, May 31, 1916Frothingham, Thomas Goddard
History
A True Account of the Battle of Jutland, May 31, 1916
Frothingham, Thomas Goddard
Jutland, Battle of, 1916; World War, 1914-1918 -- Naval operations
Lord Jellicoe’s arguments show that he followed a line of conduct well
considered in advance,[18] and he writes with a sincere conviction
that his act in breaking off the battle was justified by the results.
In explaining the many advantages possessed by the weaker German fleet
Admiral Jellicoe also reveals disappointing conditions in backwardness
of methods on the part of the British Navy. There was not alone the
lack of modern methods in range-finding and director fire-control,
but also in torpedo attack and defense, and in preparation for action
“under night conditions.” (J)[19] It is something of a shock to read
that the stronger British fleet went into the Jutland battle with a
handicap in these essentials that became a factor to prevent a decisive
action.[20] Lord Jellicoe makes a very strong plea for his contention
that, under the existing conditions of smoke, mist and darkness, with
the German fleet skilfully taking advantage of these conditions, and
with the handicaps of the Grand Fleet in construction, equipment, and
methods to contend with these tactics and conditions, there was no
opportunity to force a decision without prohibitive risks of losing the
existing supremacy of the British Navy on the seas.[21]
[18] Lord Jellicoe had sent to the Admiralty a formal dispatch
(October 30, 1914) stating his conviction that the
Germans would “rely to a great extent on submarines,
mines and torpedoes,” (J) and defining his own “tactical
methods in relation to these forms of attack.” (J) On
November 7, 1914, the Admiralty approved the “views
stated therein.” Lord Jellicoe in his book cites this
Admiralty approval of 1914 as applying to the Battle of
Jutland.
[19] “The German organization at night is very good. Their
system of recognition signals is excellent. Ours are
practically nil. Their searchlights are superior to ours,
and they use them with great effect. Finally, their
method of firing at night gives excellent results. I am
reluctantly of the opinion that under night conditions we
have a good deal to learn from them.” (J)
[20] “The British Fleet was not properly equipped for fighting
an action at night. The German fleet was. Consequently
to fight them at night would only have been to court
disaster. Lord Jellicoe’s business was to preserve the
Grand Fleet, the main defense of the Empire as well as of
the Allied cause, not to risk its existence.” Sir Percy
Scott, _Fifty Years in the Royal Navy_.
[21] See _A Guide to the Military History of The World War_,
pp. 320-22.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account