Account of the Terrific and Fatal Riot at the New-York Astor Place Opera House on the Night of May 10th, 1849: With the Quarrels of Forrest and Macready Including All the Causes which Led to that Awful Tragedy Wherein an Infuriated Mob was Quelled by the Public Authorities and Military, with its Mournful Termination in the Sudden Death or Mutilation of more than Fifty Citizens, with Full and Authentic Particulars — John Shaqi
Account of the Terrific and Fatal Riot at the New-York Astor Place Opera House on the Night of May 10th, 1849: With the Quarrels of Forrest and Macready Including All the Causes which Led to that Awful Tragedy Wherein an Infuriated Mob was Quelled by the Public Authorities and Military, with its Mournful Termination in the Sudden Death or Mutilation of more than Fifty Citizens, with Full and Authentic ParticularsAnonymous
History
Account of the Terrific and Fatal Riot at the New-York Astor Place Opera House on the Night of May 10th, 1849: With the Quarrels of Forrest and Macready Including All the Causes which Led to that Awful Tragedy Wherein an Infuriated Mob was Quelled by the Public Authorities and Military, with its Mournful Termination in the Sudden Death or Mutilation of more than Fifty Citizens, with Full and Authentic Particulars
Anonymous
Astor Place Riot, New York, N.Y., 1849; Forrest, Edwin, 1806-1872; Macready, William Charles, 1793-1873; Mobs -- New York (State) -- New York; Riots -- New York (State) -- New York
Those who were actively engaged in the scenes we have described,
experience different feelings in regard to it. The mob was made up
mainly of well-meaning, but ignorant, rash, and misguided men. The best
feelings of our nature, when they are perverted, may produce the worst
consequences. In this case, a feeling of patriotism, and a sense of
justice, were the ruling motives of those who violated the laws, broke
the peace of the community, defied the constituted authorities, and
caused the death of twenty-three human beings. They acted in all good
conscience, but an unenlightened or misguided conscience is no security
against wrong. Some of the worst deeds that were ever committed, were
done “in all good conscience.” Thus Christ was crucified by a Jewish
mob, and said, “Father, forgive them, they know not what they do.”
Thus, in all ages, the worst acts have been committed from the best of
motives.
The authorities are probably satisfied with having maintained law
and order, though at a terrible sacrifice, and the press has almost
unanimously sustained them. But it should be remembered that almost
all men are liable to temporary excitements. Mobs are affected with a
kind of insanity. The madness of a crowd seems to be infectious. These
rioters may, in their calm moments, be good and quiet citizens. We have
seen some of the most sober and moral communities excited into a fury
of passion. At any rate, they are brethren, and should be dealt with in
love and kindness.
But law and order must be maintained; very true—it must be done at all
hazards, but it should be done prudently, and with the least possible
sacrifice. Humanity has its claims as well as law; and it may not
be necessary to the maintenance of public order, that ignorant and
misguided men, laboring under a temporary madness should be shot down
like dogs, if they can be controlled by means more gentle.
The military acted naturally, under the circumstances. They were placed
in an ugly position by the authorities, suffered severely for it, and
obeyed their orders. No doubt, they regretted the fatal necessity. Some
idea of the probable feelings of those who fired the fatal volleys,
may be judged of from the fact that a brother of Mr. Gedney, who was
shot dead at the first fire, was a member of one of the companies that
fired the volleys. All men are brethren—but here was brother against
brother, in a sense that the most unfeeling can appreciate.
A distinguished clergyman of this city, preaching on the subject of
the riot, says of Macready and his right to act—“Though he had been
the meanest of his kind, he should have been protected here to the
conclusion of his announced engagement, if an army of ten thousand
men had been required to wait upon his movements, and a ship of war
chartered to convey him to his native land. We have done something to
vindicate order and law, and we ought to have done more.”
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account