Address delivered before the British Association assembled at BelfastTyndall, John
Religion
Address delivered before the British Association assembled at Belfast
Tyndall, John
Evolution; Religion and science; Science -- History
The strain upon the mind during the stationary period towards
ultra-terrestrial things, to the neglect of problems close at hand,
was sure to provoke reaction. But the reaction was gradual; for the
ground was dangerous, a power being at hand competent to crush the
critic who went too far. To elude this power and still allow
opportunity for the expression of opinion, the doctrine of 'twofold
truth' was invented, according to which an opinion might be held;
'theologically' and the opposite opinion 'philosophically.'[12] Thus
in the thirteenth century the creation of the world in six days, and
the unchangeableness of the individual soul which had been so
distinctly affirmed by St. Thomas Aquinas, were both denied
philosophically, but admitted to be true as articles of the Catholic
faith. When Protagoras uttered the maxim which brought upon him so
much vituperation, that' opposite assertions are equally true,' he
simply meant that human beings differed so much from each other that
what was subjectively true to the one might be subjectively untrue to
the other. The great Sophist never meant to play fast and loose with
the truth by saying that one of two opposite assertions, made by the
same individual, could possibly escape being a lie. It was not
'sophistry,' but the dread of theologic vengeance that generated this
double dealing with conviction; and it is astonishing to notice what
lengths were possible to men who were adroit in the use of artifices
of this kind.
Towards the close of the stationary period a word-weariness, if I may
so express it, took more and more possession of men's minds.
Christendom had become sick of the School philosophy and its verbal
wastes, which led to no issue, but left the intellect in everlasting
haze. Here and there was heard the voice of one impatiently crying
in the wilderness, 'Not unto Aristotle, not unto subtle hypothesis,
not unto church, Bible, or blind tradition, must we turn for a
knowledge of the universe, but to the direct investigation of Nature
by observation and experiment.' In 1543 the epoch-making work of
Copernicus on the paths of the heavenly bodies appeared. The total
crash of Aristotle's closed universe with the earth at its centre
followed as a consequence, and 'the earth moves!' became a kind of
watchword among intellectual freemen. Copernicus was Canon of the
Church of Frauenburg, in the diocese of Ermeland. For
three-and-thirty years he had withdrawn himself from the world and
devoted himself to the consolidation of his great scheme of the solar
system. He made its blocks eternal; and even to those who feared it
and desired its overthrow it was so obviously strong that they
refrained for a time from meddling with it. In the last year of the
life of Copernicus his book appeared: it is said that the old man
received a copy of it a few days before his death, and then departed
in peace.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account