"Comparing the first period after the operation with the period before,
it is found that only about one-third showed improvement, and a little
over half were doing poorer work. By comparing an average of _all_ work
done subsequent to the operation with what was done before, it became
evident that improvement in school work is not often observed until
after a year from the date of the operation."
In the cases that had records for twenty months, 16 show that better
work was done in the second period after the operation than in the
period before.
TABLE A
Table showing where improvement begins.
_Per Cent of cases showing improvement_
Period 1 Period 2 Period 3
Based on 31 cases 32.2
Based on 18 cases 33.3 66.6
Based on 11 cases 36.3 63.5 100
Based on all groups 33.9 65. 100
These cases were compared with a control group chosen at random. They
comprised a total of 100 children who had records for four consecutive
school years.
TABLE B
Table showing how time of improvement of "operated cases" compares with
improvement among children at random.
Period 1 Period 2 Period 3
A--Per cent of 31 cases 32.2
(operated upon)
Per cent of 100 children 42
at random
B--Per cent of 18 children--20 33.3 66.6
months (operated upon)
Per cent of 100 children at 42 41
random
C--Per cent of 11 cases for 30 36.3 63.5 100
months (operated upon)
Per cent of 100 children at 42 41 41
random
"... Immediately after operation, there seems to be a dropping off in
the quality of school work done," but thereafter a marked improvement
while the random group shows a comparatively static percentage of
improvement from year to year. The conclusion of the author is:
"Here seems good reason to believe that the removal of diseased tonsils
and adenoids is a factor in beneficially influencing the mental life of
the school child. Not only is the health impaired by failure to remove
these diseased parts but the mental life and activity of the child as
well."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account