Again, in only five pairs does the gain of the control exceed that of
the test case, while in the remaining sixteen pairs the gains of the
test cases are greater than those of their respective controls. The
greatest loss of test as compared to control is 4.2 lbs., while the
largest gain is 7.9. It would seem then, that after a six months'
interval a child who has been operated on for adenoids and tonsils will
tend to show a slightly greater increase in weight than a child who
continues to suffer from the defects. The very small group renders this
conclusion far from assured. Since it doubtless takes some little time
to recover from the effects of the operation, and since there is
comparatively little gain in weight in a six months' interval, it would
be well to extend the experiment over another year. For the greater
reliability of results, some degree of after-care should be given the
operative cases, the control cases of course receiving the same
treatment. While this was impracticable in the present study, it
happened that three pairs of cases were members of a nutrition class,
and therefore underwent some hygienic treatment. In one pair, (no. 11)
the test case lost .3 of a pound, while the control gained .9. The test
cases of pairs 7 and 10 gained .8 lb. and 2.1 lbs. respectively, over
and above their controls. However, these three cases alone are of little
significance.
A study of increase in height suffers even more than one of weight gains
from the short interval which elapsed between measurements. Normally,
there is very little growth in six months. There are only nineteen pairs
of cases in this portion of the study, a fact which renders it of even
less value. However, results are offered for what they are worth. The
smallest increase in height (.3 in.) is in the test group, while the
greatest growth (3.5 in.) is also in the test group. There is, however,
a gain of 3.3 inches in the control group as well as one of only .4
inches. There are seven pairs in which the test group growth is less
than that of the controls, one in which the two are equal, and in the
remaining eleven the growth of the test cases exceeds that of the
controls. The variability
TABLE III
Gain in weight, 6 months, 21 pairs
N[16] Test Group (A) Control Group (B) Lbs.
Test 1 Test 2 Gain Test 1 Test 2 Gain A-B
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account