In presenting the results of this experiment, the writer is especially
indebted to Professor R. S. Woodworth, under whose auspices the
investigation was carried out, for his interest and advice; and to Dr.
Leta S. Hollingworth for the suggestion of the problem, practical aid in
obtaining subjects, and constant inspiration. She is indebted to the
School of Education, Teachers' College, for the provision of operative
treatment for the subjects; to Mr. Mark and his officers at Public
School 64; and to Superintendent O'Brien of the Manhattan Eye, Ear and
Throat Hospital. It must be said that by their hearty and generous
cooperation they have contributed in a large measure to whatever value
this study may possess.
ADENOIDS AND DISEASED TONSILS: THEIR EFFECT UPON GENERAL INTELLIGENCE
CHAPTER I.
PREVIOUS LITERATURE
Concerning the Relation of Nose and Throat Defects to Intelligence
There are very few experimental studies of the relation between
intelligence and the two defects considered here. There are a few
statistical studies, and among earlier writers especially many
statements of opinion on the matter. Characteristic of the latter is the
following extract from an article in the Boston Medical and Surgical
Journal, March, 1886.[1]
[1]: F. Hooper, M. D., quoting from a paper by B. Frankel.
"... it is a fact that their intelligence may become weakened and their
characters changed. They do not progress in their studies at school, are
generally at the bottom of the class and remain in it longer than the
prescribed time.... That the impairment of intellect and want of energy
manifested by these children is real, and not merely in the expression
of countenance, is made evident by watching these same children after
the growths have been removed. To the gratification and astonishment of
the parents and teachers, the children hitherto sluggish and dull of
comprehension, now make rapid progress, and their comrades soon cease to
make a laughing stock of them."
The following quotation from an article by Irving Townsend, M. D., is in
the same vein:[2]
[2]: Adenoid Growths of the Naso-pharynx. Read before the
Homeopathic Medical Society of New York, February, 1895.
"Aprosexia is the rather imposing term applied to the imperfect or
arrested mental development attributed to this condition. This is
denied by some authors, who claim that the dullness of comprehension and
inattention are only apparent, and due only to defective hearing. A
strong evidence of its reality lies in the fact that these children show
most marvelous intellectual development after the removal of the growth,
even in cases where deafness is not markedly improved."
A most enthusiastic denouncer of adenoids and abnormal tonsils is H.
Addington Bruce. Concerning their direful effects upon the intelligence,
and the magical results of their removal, he is continually
reiterating:[3]
[3]: H. Addington Bruce, Psychology and Parenthood, 1916.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account