Aesthetical and philosophical essays : $b introducing the dissertation on the "connection between the animal and spiritual man"Schiller, Friedrich
Philosophy
Aesthetical and philosophical essays : $b introducing the dissertation on the "connection between the animal and spiritual man"
Schiller, Friedrich
Aesthetics; Philosophy
So long as it remains possible for inclination and duty to meet in the
same object and in a common desire, this _representation_ of the moral
sense by the æsthetic sense may not draw after it positively evil
consequences, though, if the matter be strictly considered, the morality
of particular actions does not gain by this agreement. But the
consequences will be quite different when sensuousness and reason have
each of them a different interest. If, for example, duty commands us to
perform an action that revolts our taste, or if taste feels itself drawn
towards an object which reason as a moral judge is obliged to condemn,
then, in fact, we suddenly encounter the necessity of distinguishing
between the requirements of the moral sense and those of the æsthetic
sense, which so long an agreement had almost confounded to such a degree
that they could not be distinguished. We must now determine their
reciprocal rights, and find which of them is the real master in our
soul. But such a long representation of the moral sense by the sense of
the beautiful has made us forget this master. When we have so long
practised this rule of obeying at once the suggestions of taste, and
when we have found the result always satisfactory, taste ends by
assuming a kind of appearance of right. As taste has shown itself
_irreproachable_ in the vigilant watch it has kept over the will, we
necessarily come to grant a certain esteem to its decisions; and it is
precisely to this esteem that inclination, with captious logic, gives
weight against the duties of conscience.
Esteem is a feeling that can only be felt for _law_, and what
corresponds to it. Whatever is entitled to esteem lays claim to an
unconditional homage. The ennobled inclination which has succeeded in
captivating our esteem will, therefore, no longer be satisfied with
being subordinate to reason; it aspires to rank alongside it. It does
not wish to be taken for a faithless subject in revolt against his
sovereign; it wishes to be regarded as a queen; and, treating reason as
its peer, to dictate, like reason, laws to the conscience. Thus, if we
listen to her, she would weigh by right equally in the scale; and then
have we not good reason to fear that interest will decide?
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account