Africana; or, the heart of heathen Africa, Volume 1 (of 2) : $b Native customs and beliefs — John Shaqi
Africana; or, the heart of heathen Africa, Volume 1 (of 2) : $b Native customs and beliefsMacdonald, Duff
Religion
Africana; or, the heart of heathen Africa, Volume 1 (of 2) : $b Native customs and beliefs
Macdonald, Duff
Africa, East -- Social life and customs; Missions -- Africa, East
For instance, a person that had never been out of England would see
nothing amiss in asking a Makua or a Machinga, “If a dog were to tear
your trousers and your housemaid were to mend them, how much would you
give her in addition to her ordinary wages?” Now the native will not
say “We wear no trousers,” “Women in our country never sew,” “No one
receives wages in our country for domestic service,” “Special services
are not defined, and if they were, the duties of a housemaid would not be
anything like what they are in England”. Instead of making statements of
this kind, which would all be interesting to his questioner, the African
will take up the question as it stands, he will consider that it is quite
worthy of the genius of a European, and will probably answer that the
housemaid would get “two fowls, one hoe, and a string of beads!” And
he may reply without the least hesitation; for if he be a professional
oracle-man, remember he has been trained all his lifetime to answer
hypothetical questions. He would reason that if a man possessed trousers,
and servants, yea, a female that obtained wages and had been taught to
sew, he ought to give her some handsome present for what she did beyond
her ordinary duties, and then our oracle would state what was his idea
of a handsome present. His answer is utterly misleading, but he deserves
credit for his polite attempt to humour the European, who forthwith
translates the answer into pounds, shillings, and pence!
Another cause of error is found in
NATIVE POLITENESS.
One evening I questioned a professional judge on a point of native law;
he replied by stating what was entirely untrue; when I pointed this
out he merely laughed at the circumstance; he thought he had invented
something that would appear better to a foreigner. He reminded me of
a Scotch guide who kept telling what was false, because the Southerns
all liked to hear that some “old king was killed beside the great big
stane”. Bishop Steere says—“In Africa they never say _no_, they always
say _yes, certainly_; but possibly you are no nearer your object”. One
must be careful never to _suggest_ an answer to a native; if the native
and his questioner are strangers to each other the former will make it a
point of etiquette to find out what answer the stranger would like, and
may by and by take occasion to compliment him on his cleverness and the
accuracy of his knowledge! Statements made in answer to direct questions
are not to be relied on unless the questioner has had years of experience
in conversation with natives, and knows the subject he converses about.
What is arrived at in an indirect manner is almost always more valuable.
I lay down these principles as to native evidence with some confidence,
as I have tried them in hundreds of cases, especially in endeavours to
fix the exact meaning of native words. One statement where the word
occurred spontaneously was worth ten statements contrived for the purpose
of eliminating the meaning.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account