Alcohol: A Dangerous and Unnecessary Medicine, How and Why: What Medical Writers SayAllen, Martha Meir
Science
Alcohol: A Dangerous and Unnecessary Medicine, How and Why: What Medical Writers Say
Allen, Martha Meir
Alcohol -- Physiological effect; Temperance
"I was a member of the Vestry of St. Marylebone, and we had in
our parish a very serious outbreak of small-pox, attended with a
considerable mortality. In his report to us Dr. Whitmore stated
that in his treatment of earlier cases of the confluent and
hemorrhagic, and malignant forms of disease, stimulants of wine
and brandy were freely administered without any apparent
benefit; and, that after consultation with Mr. Cross, the
resident surgeon, they resolved to substitute simple
nutriments, such as milk, eggs and beef-tea, at frequent
intervals, with discontinuance of stimulants altogether. The
result of the change was most satisfactory, and many bad cases
did well, which under the stimulant plan they believed would
have terminated fatally. Again I was struck very much by a
report made by Mr. Cadbury, in which that gentleman showed the
course that was going on in various hospitals. The amount of
alcohol in twelve hospitals in London, taken by the inpatients,
varied in ounces from 37,531 in one establishment to 300,094 in
another during the year 1878. I also found, from the same
author, that the whole cost in St. George's Union Infirmary for
the year 1878 was L8. 3s. 6d., amongst 2,496 patients, while the
cost of the same number at the average of the twelve hospitals
was L124. About this same time I also remarked that in many of
the public institutions of England there was a reduction
something similar in kind, if not to the same extent, and that
the number of persons who suffered seemed to make better
recoveries than those who were taking the free amount of
stimulant. The effect of these observations chimed in very
remarkably with the physiological experiments it had been my
duty to carry out, and which tended to show in a most striking
manner that the action of alcohol in the body very much differed
from the ordinary opinion that had been held upon it, and
thereupon, in my own practice, I abandoned the use of alcohol,
and began to give instead small quantities of simple,
nourishing, dietic food, a course I pursued up to the present
time with the most satisfactory results, results I have never
felt any occasion to regret. By these steps, learned in the
first place from the study of alcohol in its action on man, I
was led to become a believer that alcohol is of no more service
in disease than it is in health, and a lengthened experience in
this matter has really confirmed the correctness of the idea."
In his last report as physician to the Temperance Hospital Dr.
Richardson made some remarkable statements upon the fallacy of the
general ideas of stimulation. So interesting are his views that they are
incorporated here:--
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account