Alcohol: A Dangerous and Unnecessary Medicine, How and Why: What Medical Writers SayAllen, Martha Meir
Science
Alcohol: A Dangerous and Unnecessary Medicine, How and Why: What Medical Writers Say
Allen, Martha Meir
Alcohol -- Physiological effect; Temperance
"I investigated the cause of inebriety, and found the medical
use of alcoholic stimulants a prominent factor in this horrible
result; I sought for expert testimony, and found Dr. N. S.
Davis, ex-President American Medical Association, saying 'that
in his ample clinical practice he had for over thirty years
tested the medical uses of alcoholics, and had _found no case of
disease and no emergency arising from accident that he could not
treat more successfully without any form of fermented or
distilled liquors than with_'; found Dr. James R. Nichols, of
Boston, so long editor of _The Journal of Chemistry_, declaring
as his deliberate scientific opinion that the entire banishment
of these liquors 'would not deprive us of a single one of the
indispensable agents which modern civilization demands'; found
Dr. Green, of Boston, saying before the physicians of that city
that it is upon the members of the medical profession and the
exceptional laws which it has always demanded, that the whole
liquor fraternity depends more than upon anything else to screen
it from opprobrium and just punishment for the evils it entails,
and that after thirty years of professional experience he felt
assured that alcoholic stimulants are not required as medicines,
and that many, if not a majority of the best physicians, now
believe them _to be worse than useless_. Meanwhile I learned
that across the sea such great physicians as Dr. Benjamin Ward
Richardson, Sir Andrew Clark, Sir Henry Thompson and Sir William
Gull held views which for their latitude were almost equally
radical; and Dr. James Edmunds, founder of the London Temperance
Hospital had demonstrated publicly and on a grand scale the more
excellent way, his hospital having 4-1/2 per cent. fewer deaths
than any other in London, taking the same run of cases, and that
the Royal Infirmary at Manchester reported the medicinal use of
alcohol fallen off 87 per cent. in recent years, with a decrease
in its death-rate of over one-third. Besides all this, and
independent of any such investigation, the 'intuitions' of our
most earnest women were leading them out of the wilderness. As
is their custom, they determined to put this matter to the test
of that 'experience which one experiences when he experiences
his own experience,' and a whole body of divinity upon the
advantages of non-alcoholic treatment could be furnished from
their evidence. I was not able personally to pursue this method,
my own condition of good health having become chronic. Away back
in 1875, in executive committee, one of our leading officers was
stricken with _angina pectoris_. A physician was promptly
summoned. 'Give her brandy,' he said, and insisted so stoutly
upon it as vital to her recovery that we should probably have
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account