My second principle was to give preference to that which is truly
German, in contradistinction from that which is Latin, or European,
or merely Christian. The Latinists of every epoch are in general
disregarded, as not being of German literature in the strict sense; yet
I have devoted eight pages to _Waltharius_ and three to _Rudlieb_, on
the ground that the matter of these poems is essentially German, albeit
their form is Latin. On the other hand, Hrotswith is not represented at
all, because, while an interesting personage in her way, she belongs to
German literature neither by her form nor by her matter. The religious
poetry of the twelfth century receives rather scant attention, partly
because it is mostly pretty poor stuff--there is not much else like the
beautiful Arnstein hymn to the Virgin, No. XIII--and partly because it
embodies ideas and feelings that belonged to medieval Christianity
everywhere.
For each selection I have given the best translation that I could find,
and where nothing satisfactory could be found in print I have made a
translation myself. Where nothing is said as to the authorship of a
translation, it is to be understood as my own. In this part of my work
I have tried to preserve the form and savor of the originals, and at the
same time to keep as close to the exact sense as the constraints of rime
and meter would allow. In Nos. XI to XVII a somewhat perplexing problem
was presented. The originals frequently have assonance instead of rime
and the verse is sometimes crude in other ways. An attempt to imitate
the assonances and crudities in modern German would simply have given
the effect of bad verse-making. On the other hand, to translate into
smooth tetrameters, with perfect rime everywhere, would have given
an illusory appearance of regularity and have made the translation
_zu schön_. (I fear that No. VII, the selections from Otfried, for the
translation of which I am not responsible, is open to this charge.) So
I adopted the expedient of a line-for-line prose version, dropping into
rime only where the modern equivalent of the Middle German took the form
of rime naturally. After regular rime becomes established--with Heinrich
von Veldeke--I have employed it in all my translations. For my
shortcomings as a German versifier I hope to be regarded with a measure
of indulgence. The question of inclusion or exclusion could not be made
to turn on the preëxistence of a good translation, because too much that
is important and interesting would have had to be omitted. I should have
been glad to take the advice of Mephisto,
Associiert euch mit einem Poeten,
but I was unable to effect a partnership of that kind.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account