An encyclopedist of the dark ages: Isidore of SevilleBrehaut, Ernest
History
An encyclopedist of the dark ages: Isidore of Seville
Brehaut, Ernest
Isidore, of Seville, Saint, -636; Thesis (Ph. D.)
The résumé that Isidore offers is strikingly complete. In this
respect he surpasses all the writers of his own and immediately
preceding periods, his scope being much more general than that of
his nearest contemporaries, Boethius and Cassiodorus. He goes back
here to the tradition of the encyclopedists of the Roman world,
Varro, Verrius Flaccus, Pliny, and Suetonius, by the last of whom he
is believed to have been especially influenced. Few writers of any
period cover the intellectual interests of their time so completely.
To understand Isidore’s mental world is nearly to reach the limits of
the knowledge of his time.[3]
[3] Nihil enim Isidorus intentatum reliquit: facultates omnes
attigit, scientias humanas divinasque pertractavit, scriptores
veteres profanos et sacros evolvit, atque in suum usum
descripsit; nec contentus etymologico suo opere scientiarum
encyclopaediam comprehendere, multa singillatim in sacrarum
litterarum interpretatione disseruit, multa in omni alio
theologiae genere, multa in philosophicis atque astronomicis
argumentis, multa in re litteraria, chronologica et historica.
Arevalo, _Prolegomena in Editionem S. Isidori Hispalensis_, cap.
1, 3.
The influence which he exerted upon the following centuries was
very great. His organization of the field of secular science,
although it amounted to no more than the laying out of a corpse,
was that chiefly accepted throughout the early medieval period. The
innumerable references to him by later writers,[4] the many remaining
manuscripts,[5] and the successive editions of his works[6] after the
invention of printing, indicate the great rôle he played.[7] From the
modern point of view the real benefit he conferred upon succeeding
centuries was that in his encyclopaedic writings he presented to
the intelligent the fact that there had been and might be such
a thing as secular science; while the blunders in which he was
continually involved, and the shallowness of his thinking, offered
a perpetual challenge to the critical power of all who read him.
There was contained in his writings also, as we shall see, the embryo
of something positive and progressive, namely, the organization of
educational subjects that was to appear definitely in the medieval
university and dominate education almost to the present day.
[4] Arevalo in his _Prolegomena_, cap. 33, collects passages
containing “laudes Isidori” from medieval writers, including
Fredegarius, Alcuin, William of Malmesbury, Vincent of Beauvais,
and others. Isidore is cited by Petrarch in a way which shows
that he was much read in his time. Petrarch is giving authorities
for his theory of poetry, and after mentioning Varro and
Suetonius, he says: “Then I can add a third name, which will
probably be better known to you, Isidore.” _Cf._ Robinson and
Rolfe, _Petrarch_, p. 263.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account