An enquiry concerning the principles of natural knowledgeWhitehead, Alfred North
Philosophy
An enquiry concerning the principles of natural knowledge
Whitehead, Alfred North
Knowledge, Theory of; Science -- Philosophy; Space and time
But Maxwell's electromagnetic equations are not thus invariant for the
Newtonian group. The result is that they must be construed as referring
to one particular consentient set of this group. It is natural to
suppose that this particular assumption arises from the fact that the
equations refer to the physical properties of a stagnant ether; and that
accordingly the consentient set presupposed in the equations is the
consentient set of this ether. The ether is identified with the ether
whose wave disturbances constitute light; and furthermore there are
practically conclusive reasons for believing light to be merely
electromagnetic disturbances which are governed by Maxwell's equations.
The motion of the earth through the ether affects other electromagnetic
phenomena in addition to those known to us as light. Such effects, as
also in the case of light, would be very small and difficult to observe.
But the effect on the capacity of a condenser of the six-monthly
reversal of the earth's velocity should under proper conditions be
observable. This is known as Trouton's experiment. Again, as in the
analogous case of light, no such effect has been observed.
9.5 The explanation [the Fitzgerald-Lorentz hypothesis] of these
failures to observe expected effects has been given, that matter as it
moves through ether automatically readjusts its shape so that its
lengths in the direction of motion are altered in a definite ratio
dependent on its velocity. The null results of the experiments are thus
completely accounted for, and the material ether evades the most obvious
method of testing its existence. If matter is thus strained by its
passage through ether, some effect on its optical properties due to the
strains might be anticipated. Such effects have been sought for, but not
observed. Accordingly with the assumption of an ether of material the
negative results of the various experiments are explained by an ad
hoc hypothesis which appears to be related to no other phenomena in
nature.
9.6 There is another way in which the motion of matter may be
balanced (so to speak) against the velocity of light. Fizeau
experimented on the passage of light through translucent moving matter,
and obtained results which Fresnel accounted for by multiplying the
refractive index of the moving medium by a coefficient dependent on its
velocity. This is Fresnel's famous 'coefficient of drag.' He accounted
for this coefficient by assuming that as the material medium in its
advance sucks in the ether, it condenses it in a proportion dependent on
the velocity. It might be expected that any theory of the relations of
matter to ether, either an ether of material or an ether of events,
would explain also this coefficient of drag.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account