An enquiry concerning the principles of natural knowledgeWhitehead, Alfred North
Philosophy
An enquiry concerning the principles of natural knowledge
Whitehead, Alfred North
Knowledge, Theory of; Science -- Philosophy; Space and time
The conclusion at once evokes the suggestion that the Lorentzian
formulae are the true formulae for transformation from the space and
time relations of a consentient set to those of a consentient
set , both sets belonging to the Newtonian group. We may
suppose that, owing to bluntness of perception, mankind has remained
satisfied with the Newtonian formulae which are a simplified version of
the true Lorentzian relations. This is the conclusion that Einstein has
urged.
Fig. 2.
10.6 These Lorentzian formulae for transformation involve two
consequences which are paradoxical if we covertly assume absolute space
and absolute time. Let and be two consentient sets
of the Newtonian group. Let an event-particle happen at the point
in the -space and at the point in
the -space, and let another event-particle happen at
points and in the two spaces respectively.
Then according to the traditional scientific outlook, and
are not discriminated from each other; and similarly for
and . Thus evidently the distance
is (on this theory) equal to
, because in fact they are symbols for the same
distance. But if the true distinction between the -space and
the -space is kept in mind, including the fact that the points
in the two spaces are radically distinct, the equality of the distances
and is not so obvious.
According to the Lorentzian formulae such corresponding distances in the
two spaces will not in general be equal.
The second consequence of the Lorentzian formulae involves a more deeply
rooted paradox which concerns our notions of time. If the two
event-particles and happen simultaneously when referred to
the points and in the -space,
they will in general not happen simultaneously when referred to the
points and in the -space. This
result of the Lorentzian formulae contradicts the assumption of one
absolute time, and makes the time-system depend on the consentient set
which is adopted as the standard of reference. Thus there is an
-time as well as an -space, and a -time as
well as -space.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account