An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of AssentNewman, John Henry
Religion
An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of Assent
Newman, John Henry
Faith; Theism
Certitude is the knowledge of a truth:—but what is once true is always
true, and cannot fail, whereas what is once known need not always be
known, and is capable of failing. It follows, that if I am certain
of a thing, I believe it will remain what I now hold it to be, even
though my mind should have the bad fortune to let it drop. Since mere
argument is not the measure of assent, no one can be called certain of
a proposition, whose mind does not spontaneously and promptly reject,
on their first suggestion, as idle, as impertinent, as sophistical, any
objections which are directed against its truth. No man is certain of
a truth, who can endure the thought of the fact of its contradictory
existing or occurring; and that not from any set purpose or effort to
reject that thought, but, as I have said, by the spontaneous action of
the intellect. What is contradictory to the truth, with its apparatus
of argument, fades out of the mind as fast as it enters it; and though
it be brought back to the mind ever so often by the pertinacity of an
opponent, or by a voluntary or involuntary act of imagination, still
that contradictory proposition and its arguments are mere phantoms and
dreams, in the light of our certitude, and their very entering into the
mind is the first step of their going out of it. Such is the position
of our minds towards the heathen fancy that Enceladus lies under
Etna; or, not to take so extreme a case, that Joanna Southcote was a
messenger from heaven, or the Emperor Napoleon really had a star. Equal
to this peremptory assertion of negative propositions is the revolt
of the mind from suppositions incompatible with positive statements
of which we are certain, whether abstract truths or facts; as that a
straight line is the longest possible distance between its two extreme
points, that Great Britain is in shape an exact square or circle, that
I shall escape dying, or that my intimate friend is false to me.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account