An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of AssentNewman, John Henry
Religion
An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of Assent
Newman, John Henry
Faith; Theism
1. We are all absolutely certain, beyond the possibility of doubt, that
Great Britain is an island. We give to that proposition our deliberate
and unconditional adhesion. There is no security on which we should
be better content to stake our interests, our property, our welfare,
than on the fact that we are living in an island. We have no fear of
any geographical discovery which may reverse our belief. We should be
amused or angry at the assertion, as a bad jest, did any one say that
we were at this time joined to the main-land in Norway or in France,
though a canal was cut across the isthmus. We are as little exposed to
the misgiving, “Perhaps we are not on an island after all,” as to the
question, “Is it quite certain that the angle in a semi-circle is a
right-angle?” It is a simple and primary truth with us, if any truth is
such; to believe it is as legitimate an exercise of assent, as there
are legitimate exercises of doubt or of opinion. This is the position
of our minds towards our insularity; yet are the arguments producible
for it (to use the common expression) in black and white commensurate
with this overpowering certitude about it?
Our reasons for believing that we are circumnavigable are such as
these:—first, we have been so taught in our childhood, and it is so in
all the maps; next, we have never heard it contradicted or questioned;
on the contrary, every one whom we have heard speak on the subject
of Great Britain, every book we have read, invariably took it for
granted; our whole national history, the routine transactions and
current events of the country, our social and commercial system, our
political relations with foreigners, imply it in one way or another.
Numberless facts, or what we consider facts, rest on the truth of it;
no received fact rests on its being otherwise. If there is anywhere a
junction between us and the continent, where is it? and how do we know
it? is it in the north or in the south? There is a manifest _reductio
ad absurdum_ attached to the notion that we can be deceived on such a
point as this.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account