An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of AssentNewman, John Henry
Religion
An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of Assent
Newman, John Henry
Faith; Theism
7. “In order to prove plainly and intelligibly,” says Dr. Samuel
Clarke, “that God is a Being, which must of necessity be endued with
perfect knowledge, ’tis to be observed that knowledge is a perfection,
without which the foregoing attributes are no perfections at all, and
without which those which follow can have no foundation. Where there
is no Knowledge, Eternity and Immensity are as nothing, and Justice,
Goodness, Mercy, and Wisdom can have no place. The idea of eternity
and omnipresence, devoid of knowledge, is as the notion of darkness
compared with that of light. ’Tis as a notion of the world without the
sun to illuminate it; ’tis as the notion of inanimate matter (which is
the atheist’s supreme cause) compared with that of light and spirit.
And as for the following attributes of Justice, Goodness, Mercy, and
Wisdom, ’tis evident that without knowledge there could not possibly be
any such things as these at all.(18)”
The argument here used in behalf of the Divine Attribute of Knowledge
comes under the general proposition that the attributes imply each
other, for the denial of one is the denial of the rest. To some minds
this thesis is self-evident; others are utterly insensible to its
force. Will it bear bringing out into words throughout the whole
series of its argumentative links? for if it does, then either those
who maintain it or those who reject it, the one or the other, will be
compelled by logical necessity to confess that they are in error. “God
is wise, if He is eternal; He is good, if He is wise; He is just, if
He is good.” What skill can so arrange these propositions, so add to
them, so combine them, that they may be able, by the force of their
juxta-position, to follow one from the other, and become one and the
same by an inevitable correlation. That is not the method by which the
argument becomes a demonstration. Such a method, used by a Theist in
controversy against men who are unprepared personally for the question,
will but issue in his retreat along a series of major propositions,
farther and farther back, till he and they find themselves in a land of
shadows, “where the light is as darkness.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account