An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of AssentNewman, John Henry
Religion
An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of Assent
Newman, John Henry
Faith; Theism
And so in like manner as regards apprehension of mental objects. If
an image derived from experience or information is stronger than an
abstraction, conception, or conclusion—if I am more arrested by our
Lord’s bearing before Pilate and Herod than by the “Justum et tenacem”
&c. of the poet, more arrested by His Voice saying to us, “Give to
him that asketh thee,” than by the best arguments of the Economist
against indiscriminate almsgiving, it does not matter for my present
purpose whether the objects give strength to the apprehension or the
apprehension gives large admittance into the mind to the object. It
is in human nature to be more affected by the concrete than by the
abstract; it may be the reverse with other beings. The apprehension,
then, may be as fairly said to possess the force which acts upon us, as
the object apprehended.
2. Real apprehension, then, may be pronounced stronger than
notional, because things, which are its objects, are confessedly
more impressive and affective than notions, which are the objects of
notional. Experiences and their images strike and occupy the mind,
as abstractions and their combinations do not. Next, passing on to
Assent, I observe that it is this variation in the mind’s apprehension
of an object to which it assents, and not any incompleteness in the
assent itself, which leads us to speak of strong and weak assents, as
if Assent itself admitted of degrees. In either mode of apprehension,
be it real or be it notional, the assent preserves its essential
characteristic of being unconditional. The assent of a Stoic to the
“Justum et tenacem” &c. may be as genuine an assent, as absolute and
entire, as little admitting of degree or variation, as distinct from an
act of inference, as the assent of a Christian to the history of our
Lord’s Passion in the Gospel.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account