An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of AssentNewman, John Henry
Religion
An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of Assent
Newman, John Henry
Faith; Theism
There is an analogy, in this respect, between Ratiocination and
Memory, though the latter may be exercised without antecedents or
media, whereas the former requires them in its very idea. At the
same time association has so much to do with memory, that we may not
unfairly consider that memory, as well as reasoning, depends on certain
previous conditions. Writing, as I have already observed, is a _memoria
technica_, or logic of memory. Now it will be found, I think, that
indispensable as is the use of letters, still, in fact, we weaken our
memory in proportion as we habituate ourselves to commit all that we
wish to remember to memorandums. Of course in proportion as our memory
is weak or over-burdened, and thereby treacherous, we cannot help
ourselves; but in the case of men of strong memory in any particular
subject-matter, as in that of dates, all artificial expedients, from
the “Thirty days has September,” &c., to the more formidable formulas
which are offered for their use, are as difficult and repulsive as
the natural exercise of memory is healthy and easy to them; just as
the clear-headed and practical reasoner, who sees conclusions at a
glance, is uncomfortable under the drill of a logician, being oppressed
and hampered, as David in Saul’s armour, by what is intended to be a
benefit.
I need not say more on this part of the subject. What is called
reasoning is often only a peculiar and personal mode of abstraction,
and so far, like memory, may be said to exist without antecedents.
It is a power of looking at things in some particular aspect, and
of determining their internal and external relations thereby. And
according to the subtlety and versatility of their gift, are men able
to read what comes before them justly, variously, and fruitfully.
Hence, too, it is, that in our intercourse with others, in business
and family matters, in social and political transactions, a word or
an act on the part of another is sometimes a sudden revelation; light
breaks in upon us, and our whole judgment of a course of events, or
of an undertaking, is changed. We determine correctly or otherwise,
as it may be; but in either case, by a sense proper to ourselves, for
another may see the objects which we are thus using, and give them
quite a different interpretation, inasmuch as he abstracts another set
of general notions from those same phenomena which present themselves
to us.
What I have been saying of Ratiocination, may be said of Taste, and
is confirmed by the obvious analogy between the two. Taste, skill,
invention in the fine arts—and so, again, discretion or judgment in
conduct—are exerted spontaneously, when once acquired, and could not
give a clear account of themselves, or of their mode of proceeding.
They do not go by rule, though to a certain point their exercise may
be analyzed, and may take the shape of an art or method. But these
parallels will come before us presently.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account