An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of AssentNewman, John Henry
Religion
An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of Assent
Newman, John Henry
Faith; Theism
And here I am brought to the bearing of these remarks upon my subject.
For this law of progress is carried out by means of the acquisition of
knowledge, of which inference and assent are the immediate instruments.
Supposing, then, the advancement of our nature, both in ourselves
individually and as regards the human family, is, to every one of us
in his place, a sacred duty, it follows that that duty is intimately
bound up with the right use of these two main instruments of fulfilling
it. And as we do not gain the knowledge of the law of progress by any
_à priori_ view of man, but by looking at it as the interpretation
which is provided by himself on a large scale in the ordinary action of
his intellectual nature, so too we must appeal to himself, as a fact,
and not to any antecedent theory, in order to find what is the law of
his mind as regards the two faculties in question. If then such an
appeal does bear me out in deciding, as I have done, that the course of
inference is ever more or less obscure, while assent is ever distinct
and definite, and yet that what is in its nature thus absolute does,
in fact follow upon what in outward manifestation is thus complex,
indirect, and recondite, what is left to us but to take things as they
are, and to resign ourselves to what we find? that is, instead of
devising, what cannot be, some sufficient science of reasoning which
may compel certitude in concrete conclusions, to confess that there is
no ultimate test of truth besides the testimony born to truth by the
mind itself, and that this phenomenon, perplexing as we may find it, is
a normal and inevitable characteristic of the mental constitution of a
being like man on a stage such as the world. His progress is a living
growth, not a mechanism; and its instruments are mental acts, not the
formulas and contrivances of language.
We are accustomed in this day to lay great stress upon the harmony
of the universe; and we have well learned the maxim so powerfully
inculcated by our own English philosopher, that in our inquiries into
its laws, we must sternly destroy all idols of the intellect, and
subdue nature by co-operating with her. Knowledge is power, for it
enables us to use eternal principles which we cannot alter. So also is
it in that microcosm, the human mind. Let us follow Bacon more closely
than to distort its faculties according to the demands of an ideal
optimism, instead of looking out for modes of thought proper to our
nature, and faithfully observing them in our intellectual exercises.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account