An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of AssentNewman, John Henry
Religion
An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of Assent
Newman, John Henry
Faith; Theism
do ten years hence, or what another should do at this time. It may
indeed happen to decide ten years hence as it does now, and to decide a
second case now as it now decides a first; still its present act is for
the present, not for the distant or the future.
State or public law is inflexible, but this mental rule is not only
minute and particular, but has an elasticity, which, in its application
to individual cases, is, as I have said, not studious to maintain the
appearance of consistency. In old times the mason’s rule which was
in use at Lesbos was, according to Aristotle, not of wood or iron,
but of lead, so as to allow of its adjustment to the uneven surface
of the stones brought together for the work. By such the philosopher
illustrates the nature of equity in contrast with law, and such is that
_phronesis_, from which the science of morals forms its rules, and
receives its complement.
In this respect of course the law of truth differs from the law of
duty, that duties change, but truths never; but, though truth is ever
one and the same, and the assent of certitude is immutable, still
the reasonings which carry us on to truth and certitude are many and
distinct, and vary with the inquirer; and it is not with assent, but
with the controlling principle in inferences that I am comparing
_phronesis_. It is with this drift that I observe that the rule of
conduct for one man is not always the rule for another, though the rule
is always one and the same in the abstract, and in its principle and
scope. To learn his own duty in his own case, each individual must have
recourse to his own rule; and if his rule is not sufficiently developed
in his intellect for his need, then he goes to some other living,
present authority, to supply it for him, not to the dead letter of a
treatise or a code. A living, present authority, himself or another,
is his immediate guide in matters of a personal, social, or political
character. In buying and selling, in contracts, in his treatment of
others, in giving and receiving, in thinking, speaking, doing, and
working, in toil, in danger, in his recreations and pleasures, every
one of his acts, to be praiseworthy, must be in accordance with this
practical sense. Thus it is, and not by science, that he perfects the
virtues of justice, self-command, magnanimity, generosity, gentleness,
and all others. _Phronesis_ is the regulating principle of every one of
them.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account