An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of AssentNewman, John Henry
Religion
An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of Assent
Newman, John Henry
Faith; Theism
Thus the Illative Sense, that is, the reasoning faculty, as exercised
by gifted, or by educated or otherwise well-prepared minds, has its
function in the beginning, middle, and end of all discussion and
inquiry, and in every step of the process. It is a rule to itself,
and appeals to no judgment beyond its own; and attends upon the whole
course of thought from antecedents to consequents, with a minute
diligence and unwearied presence, which is impossible to a cumbrous
apparatus of verbal reasoning, though, in communicating with others,
words are the only instrument we possess, and a serviceable, though
imperfect instrument.
One function indeed there is of Logic, to which I have referred in
the preceding sentence, which the Illative Sense does not and cannot
perform. It supplies no common measure between mind and mind, as being
nothing else than a personal gift or acquisition. Few there are, as I
said above, who are good reasoners on all subject-matters. Two men, who
reason well each in his own province of thought, may, one or both of
them, fail and pronounce opposite judgments on a question belonging to
some third province. Moreover, all reasoning being from premisses, and
those premisses arising (if it so happen) in their first elements from
personal characteristics, in which men are in fact in essential and
irremediable variance one with another, the ratiocinative talent can do
no more than point out where the difference between them lies, how far
it is immaterial, when it is worth while continuing an argument between
them, and when not.
Now of the three main occasions of the exercise of the Illative Sense,
which I have been insisting on, and which are the measure of its range,
the start, the course, and the issue of an inquiry, I have already,
in treating of Informal Inference, shown the place it holds in the
final resolution of concrete questions. Here then it is left to me
to illustrate its presence and action in relation to the elementary
premisses, and, again, to the conduct of an argument. And first of the
latter.
1.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account