An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of AssentNewman, John Henry
Religion
An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of Assent
Newman, John Henry
Faith; Theism
It appears from what has been said, that, though Real Assent is not
intrinsically operative, it accidentally and indirectly affects
practice. It is in itself an intellectual act, of which the object is
presented to it by the imagination; and though the pure intellect does
not lead to action, nor the imagination either, yet the imagination has
the means, which pure intellect has not, of stimulating those powers of
the mind from which action proceeds. Real Assent then, or Belief, as it
may be called, viewed in itself, that is, simply as Assent, does not
lead to action; but the images in which it lives, representing as they
do the concrete, have the power of the concrete upon the affections and
passions, and by means of these indirectly become operative. Still this
practical influence is not invariable, nor to be relied on; for given
images may have no tendency to affect given minds, or to excite them to
action. Thus, a philosopher or a poet may vividly realize the brilliant
rewards of military genius or of eloquence, without wishing either to
be a commander or an orator. However, on the whole, broadly contrasting
Belief with Notional Assent and with Inference, we shall not, with this
explanation, be very wrong in pronouncing that acts of Notional Assent
and of Inference do not affect our conduct, and acts of Belief, that
is, of Real Assent, do (not necessarily, but do) affect it.
I have scarcely spoken of Inference since my Introductory Chapter,
though I intend, before I conclude, to consider it fully; but I have
said enough to admit of my introducing it here in contrast with Real
Assent or Belief, and that contrast is necessary in order to complete
what I have been saying about the latter. Let me then, for the sake
of the latter, be allowed here to say, that, while Assent, or Belief,
presupposes some apprehension of the things believed, Inference
requires no apprehension of the things inferred; that in consequence,
Inference is necessarily concerned with surfaces and aspects; that it
begins with itself, and ends with itself; that it does not reach as
far as facts; that it is employed upon formulas; that, as far as it
takes real objects of whatever kind into account, such as motives and
actions, character and conduct, art, science, taste, morals, religion,
it deals with them, not as they are, but simply in its own line, as
materials of argument or inquiry, that they are to it nothing more than
major and minor premisses and conclusions. Belief, on the other hand,
being concerned with things concrete, not abstract, which variously
excite the mind from their moral and imaginative properties, has for
its object, not only directly what is true, but inclusively what is
beautiful, useful, admirable, heroic; objects which kindle devotion,
rouse the passions, and attach the affections; and thus it leads the
way to actions of every kind, to the establishment of principles, and
the formation of character, and is thus again intimately connected with
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account